Finding the outcome of a police misconduct hearing
A hearing notice tells you that a hearing is planned and what is alleged. It does not tell you what was decided. The outcome is published separately, usually by the force, and sometimes only for a few weeks. These are the places to look.
The force's website
Forces publish hearing notices and outcomes on their own websites, often on a page about misconduct hearings or professional standards. The chair of a hearing must normally require the force to publish the outcome report as soon as practicable after the officer has been told the outcome, and to keep it there for at least 28 days. That is a minimum. A force may keep a report up for longer, but some take outcomes down once the 28 days have passed, so look soon after the hearing date.
When there is no outcome to find
An outcome may be missing because:
- the hearing has been postponed, or has not happened yet;
- the chair held all or part of it in private, or banned publication of some details;
- the report was redacted, or the chair decided it should not be published, for example to avoid harming a criminal case, a witness or national security; or
- the outcome was published but has since been taken down.
Leaving the force does not always end a case: a former officer can still face a gross misconduct hearing.
The barred list
If the officer was dismissed, or would have been dismissed had they not left, they will normally appear on the College of Policing's barred list, which can be searched online. Entries stay on the public list for five years. The College holds some back, for example where publishing could prejudice criminal proceedings, and police staff are not on the public list.
IOPC investigation summaries
If the Independent Office for Police Conduct (IOPC) investigated, its website may have a summary of the investigation and its outcome. Most summaries leave out the names of the people involved. Full reports, where published, are removed after six months, while summaries stay up for five years. Some are not published at all, for example in cases involving sexual offences.
Appeals
An officer can appeal to a Police Appeals Tribunal, which can change the finding or the outcome. Where the tribunal's chair requires it, the force publishes the tribunal's decision on its website for at least 28 days, so it is worth looking again some weeks after the hearing.
News reports
Hearings are public, so journalists can attend and report them. A news report can be a lasting record of an outcome after the force has taken its own report down.
Asking under Freedom of Information
You can ask a force for an outcome under the Freedom of Information Act, but it may refuse because the report is personal information about the officer (section 40). In one case about the Metropolitan Police, the ICO agreed that some outcome reports removed after 28 days could be withheld, while others could be released once the details that identified the officers were taken out.
Why PoliceFOI may not have it
PoliceFOI holds the hearing notices, and some outcomes, that a number of forces published on their websites, collected up to the date given on our how we collect page. Most forces are not covered, we do not follow each case to its end, and we do not hold outcomes published later or on pages we did not read. So a notice here may have no outcome beside it even where the force has published one. The force's website is the authoritative source. If you are named in a notice on PoliceFOI, you can ask us to remove your name.