2023/26030 - Accident near A48Disclosure log response · Gwent Police
2023/26030 - Accident near A48
Read it at Gwent Police's website
- Published
- 9 Jun 2023
- Published by
- Gwent Police
- Outcome
- Refused
- Exemptions
- Section 30 Investigations and proceedings
- Section 31 Law enforcement
- Section 40 Personal information
- Source
- Gwent Police's website
- Recorded by PoliceFOI
- 2 Sept 2026
We read the outcome and the exemptions automatically from the response's own words, so this can be wrong: report a mistake. What the outcomes and codes mean.
In full, as Gwent Police published it
We show a record in full only where its publisher's terms allow it. Most police forces in England and Wales publish under the same publication scheme terms: anyone may reproduce a force's own material free of charge if it is accurate and not misleading and the source and copyright are acknowledged, but not for any commercial purpose. PoliceFOI is published by a company, so we treat our use as commercial, and for those forces we show each record's title and summary, with a link to the original, until the force agrees to more. A few forces' terms are stricter still. None of these terms covers material owned by someone else, or a force's logo, so we link to such material rather than copy it.
2023/26030 - Accident near A48
REQUEST
Regarding the car crash in Cardiff, in which two people were left undiscovered whilst three of their friends were killed, I understand the police helicopter was called out at around 11.50pm on the Sunday that resulted in the vehicle being located near the A48. Please disclose, preferably by PDF, any pocket notebook entry of the officer that called for the police helicopter - the officer being one who may have been at, or was at, the scene/near the scene and reported this so that it led to the helicopter being called that went to the area and located the vehicle. The pocket notebook entry that may record being informed of or noticing that the car was there or may be there and/or noting that they called for the helicopter or any conversation they had with someone that then had the helicopter called out.
RESPONSE
Files
- File Document, 170 KB
The original
The text of this file
FREEDOM OF INFORMATION REQUEST
FREEDOM OF INFORMATION REQUEST 2023/ 26030
Dear [requester],
Thank you for your recent request under the Freedom of Information Act 2000.
Section 1 of the Freedom of Information Act 2000 (FOIA) places two duties on public authorities. Unless exemptions apply, the first duty at, Section 1(1) (a), is to confirm or deny whether the information specified in a request is held. The second duty at, Section1 (1) (b), is to disclose information that has been confirmed as being held.
The information that you are seeking is in relation to the following:
REQUEST
Regarding the car crash in Cardiff, in which two people were left undiscovered whilst three of their friends were killed, I understand the police helicopter was called out at around 11.50pm on the Sunday that resulted in the vehicle being located near the A48. Please disclose, preferably by PDF, any pocket notebook entry of the officer that called for the police helicopter - the officer being one who may have been at, or was at, the scene/near the scene and reported this so that it led to the helicopter being called that went to the area and located the vehicle. The pocket notebook entry that may record being informed of or noticing that the car was there or may be there and/or noting that they called for the helicopter or any conversation they had with someone that then had the helicopter called out.
RESPONSE
Gwent Police and South Wales Police have referred the matter to the Independent Office for Police Conduct and their investigation is ongoing. Gwent Police continues to support the investigation.
Please note, South Wales Police are responsible for carrying out a detailed investigation regarding this incident as it is within their jurisdiction.
Section 31(1)(a)(b) Law Enforcement
(1) Information which is not exempt information by virtue of section 30 is exempt information if its disclosure under this Act would, or would be likely to prejudice -
(a) the prevention or detection of crime
(b) the apprehension or prosecution of offenders
Section 31 is a prejudice based qualified exemption and as such there is a requirement to provide details of the harm as well as the public interest test.
Section 31 Evidence of Harm
Under the Act, we cannot, and do not request the motives of any application for information. We have no doubt that the vast majority of requests made under the Act are legitimate and the applicants do not have any ulterior motives. However, in disclosing information to one applicant, we are expressing a willingness to provide it to anyone in the world. This means that a disclosure to a genuinely interested and concerned person automatically opens it up for a similar disclosure, including those who would use the information to gain an advantage over our ability to exercise our core function which is Law Enforcement.
In considering whether or not this information should be disclosed, consideration has been given to the potential harm that could be caused by disclosure.
The police service is charged with enforcing the law, preventing and detecting crime and protecting the communities we serve. The general public are also aware that modern day policing is intelligence led and that there are changes on a day to day basis. Disclosure of this information would divulge the forces’ tactical capability in respect of this area of policing which would cause operational harm to the Gwent Police Force as well as potentially place officer’s safety at great risk as well as that of the general public by affecting our ability to fulfil our core function of law enforcement. The release of such information would be invaluable to those with criminal intent as criminals would be able to identify in which areas within the force resources are weak and use this knowledge to their own advantage in furthering criminal activity around the force.
This would or would be likely to prejudice the prevention or detection of crime and the apprehension or prosecution of offenders.
Public Interest Test:
Section 31 - Considerations favouring disclosure
Factors favouring the disclosure of this information would include better awareness may reduce crime or lead to more information from the public
Section 31 - Considerations favouring non-disclosure
However factors favouring non-disclosure would be that it would compromise law enforcement tactics and more crime could be committed. This would have an impact on police resources and would hinder the prevention or detection of crime and place individuals at risk.
Balance Test
After considering the advantages and disadvantages in disclosure it falls upon Gwent Police to conduct a balance test on the issues. The strongest arguments for release which is better awareness may reduce crime or lead to more information from the public need to be weighed against the strongest argument for non-release which in this case is Effective Law Enforcement. The Police Service is tasked with the prevention and detection of crime and protecting the public. Whilst there is a public interest in better awareness may reduce crime or lead to more information from the public there is very strong public interest in safeguarding the protection of the public and the effective use of police resources.
Therefore, in all the circumstance of the case, the public interest in maintaining the exemption outweighs the public interest in disclosing the information.
Section 40(2) Personal Information
The exemption applicable to the information you have requested for this question can be found at Section 40(2) Personal Information, of the Act and this refusal notice is issued under Section 17.
Due to the low numbers, the chances of identification are extremely high.
Information of this nature is the personal sensitive information of that individual.
To make a disclosure here would be in breach of the first GDPR data protection principle (DPA Act 2018) which is for data to be processed lawfully, fairly and transparently. Also, it may lead to the identification of individuals concerned or permit further information to be gleaned around the circumstances of each case.
Gwent Police is withholding the information you have requested on the basis that the exemption contained in s 40(2) of the Freedom of Information Act applies in that the information you have requested is personal data of third parties and the disclosure of the data would breach one of the principles contained in the Data Protection Act. The relevant principle is the first principle which states that:
Personal data shall be processed fairly and lawfully and in particular shall not be processed unless –
(a) at least one of the conditions in Schedule 2 is met and
(b) in the case of sensitive personal data, at least one of the conditions in Schedule 3 is met
It is only necessary to consider (a) in respect of the information requested. The relevant condition in Schedule 2 is condition 6 which states that:
"The processing is necessary for the purposes of legitimate interests pursued by the data controller or by the third party or parties to whom the data are disclosed, except where the processing is unwarranted in any particular case by reason of prejudice to the rights and freedoms or legitimate interests of the data subject"
Freedom of Information Act is a public disclosure regime, not a private regime. Any information disclosed under the Act is thereafter deemed to be in the public domain, and therefore freely available to the public and will be published on the Gwent Police website.
If, upon receiving a response to a freedom of information request, you are unhappy with the outcome, you may request an internal review. This should be made within 40 working days of the initial response.
Please note, any written reply from an applicant expressing dissatisfaction with an authority’s response to a request for any information will be treated as a complaint and will automatically lead to an internal review.
Thank you for your interest in Gwent Police.
© Gwent Police. Reproduced for non-commercial purposes from https://www.gwent.police.uk/foi-ai/gwent-police/disclosure2/2023/06---june/202326030---accident-near-a48/ under Gwent Police's publication scheme terms, which allow free reproduction if accurate and not misleading, with the source and copyright acknowledged. The text only, as read from the published documents; material owned by others is not covered. Collected on 2 September 2026; Gwent Police may have changed or withdrawn it since.
If this text names you or you own part of it, ask us to take the full text down: it is hidden as soon as you send the form, and the title and summary stay.
Related releases
- Accelerated Misconduct Hearing Former PC 1801 Paul Chadwick Misconduct hearing notice · Gwent Police · 8 Sept 2026
- Misconduct Hearing PC 2366 Jonathan Graham Misconduct hearing notice · Gwent Police · 7 Sept 2026
- 2026/29507 - Trauma Informed Training Disclosure log response · Gwent Police · 1 Jul 2026
- 2025/28996 - Enforcement of parking offences Disclosure log response · Gwent Police · 27 Mar 2026
- 2025/29012 - Phone Theft 2024-25 Disclosure log response · Gwent Police · 27 Mar 2026
Ask us to remove a name from this page (free) · Report a mistake