2025/28531 - Supreme Court RulingDisclosure log response · Gwent Police
2025/28531 - Supreme Court Ruling
Read it at Gwent Police's website
- Published
- 5 Aug 2025
- Published by
- Gwent Police
- Outcome
- Refused
- Exemptions
- Section 36 Prejudice to the effective conduct of public affairs
- Section 40 Personal information
- Source
- Gwent Police's website
- Recorded by PoliceFOI
- 2 Sept 2026
We read the outcome and the exemptions automatically from the response's own words, so this can be wrong: report a mistake. What the outcomes and codes mean.
In full, as Gwent Police published it
We show a record in full only where its publisher's terms allow it. Most police forces in England and Wales publish under the same publication scheme terms: anyone may reproduce a force's own material free of charge if it is accurate and not misleading and the source and copyright are acknowledged, but not for any commercial purpose. PoliceFOI is published by a company, so we treat our use as commercial, and for those forces we show each record's title and summary, with a link to the original, until the force agrees to more. A few forces' terms are stricter still. None of these terms covers material owned by someone else, or a force's logo, so we link to such material rather than copy it.
2025/28531 - Supreme Court Ruling
REQUEST
Under the terms of the Freedom of Information Act 2000, please supply me with full answers to each of the following questions regarding your force's policies in light of the Supreme Court ruling in the For Women Scotland case and subsequent Equality and Human Rights Commission guidance.
1.
Has your force sent any messages to officers or staff regarding the ruling and its implications? If so, please provide a copy
2.
Has your force changed or is it considering changing its policies on use of toilets/changing rooms for transgender people? If so, please provide details
3.
Has your force changed or is it considering changing its policy on search of detainees/suspects by transgender officers/staff? If so, please provide details
4.
Has your force held any meetings with external LGBT+ groups or internal LGBT+ staff networks since the ruling? If so, please provide details of the groups attending and the minutes of the meeting
RESPONSE
Files
- File PDF, 398 KB
The original
The text of this file
FREEDOM OF INFORMATION REQUEST
FREEDOM OF INFORMATION REQUEST 2025/28531
Dear [requester],
Thank you for your recent request under the Freedom of Information Act 2000.
Section 1 of the Freedom of Information Act 2000 (FOIA) places two duties on
public authorities. Unless exemptions apply, the first duty at, Section 1(1) (a), is to
confirm or deny whether the information specified in a request is held. The second
duty at, Section1 (1) (b), is to disclose information that has been confirmed as being
held.The information that you are seeking is in relation to the following:
REQUEST
Under the terms of the Freedom of Information Act 2000, please supply me with full
answers to each of the following questions regarding your force's policies in light of
the Supreme Court ruling in the For Women Scotland case and subsequent Equality
and Human Rights Commission guidance.1. Has your force sent any messages to officers or staff regarding the ruling and
its implications? If so, please provide a copy
2. Has your force changed or is it considering changing its policies on use of
toilets/changing rooms for transgender people? If so, please provide details
3. Has your force changed or is it considering changing its policy on search of
detainees/suspects by transgender officers/staff? If so, please provide details
4. Has your force held any meetings with external LGBT+ groups or internal
LGBT+ staff networks since the ruling? If so, please provide details of the
groups attending and the minutes of the meetingRESPONSE
1. Has your force sent any messages to officers or staff regarding the ruling
and its implications? If so, please provide a copyYes. On Wednesday 23 rd April, in the Gwent Police weekly internal bulletin on our
force intranet site , the below message was shared with all officers and staff by the
Gwent Police Chief Officer Support Team.Copy of Gwent Police internal message below:
“UK Supreme Court ruling on the Equality Act | Information for colleagues
You will have heard that the UK Supreme Court has ruled that under the Equality Act
2010, the terms ‘woman’ and ‘man’ refer exclusively to biological sex and not to gender
identity.In making the ruling, Lord Hodge stressed that transgender people are a ‘vulnerable
and often harassed minority’ and remain protected from discrimination under the
characteristic of gender reassignment under the Equality Act.While the ruling offers legal clarity, policing will need time to carefully consider the full
implications of the court’s decision, as will many other public bodies.Our policies and guidance will remain the same while we wait for new NPCC
guidanceThe National Police Chiefs Council (NPCC) will develop national guidance for all
forces. Until we know more and have reviewed that guidance in detail, our current
policies and guidance remain in place.Please continue as you have previously in terms of your use of our facilities and when
directing members of the public who may be using our stations. For officers, please
continue to conduct searches in line with our current policy, training and guidance.We will issue further updates via The Beat and The Bulletin. If you would like to know
more at any stage, please contact T/ACC Nick McLain, our culture lead.Support for all colleagues
We want to foster an inclusive workplace where everyone feels they belong and are
safe. Our unity centres on our shared value of compassion and the ability to listen to
different perspectives and experiences. We are here to support, not debate.We understand that officers and staff may be affected by this ruling on a personal
level, whether you are worried for your own wellbeing or that of family, friends or
partners.Our networks continue to offer advice and support, with a range of wellbeing support
options available too:• GEN network
• LGBT+ network
• Men’s health forum
• Wellbeing supportYou can also contact external support organisations:
Mermaids charity for trans children and young people and their families Homepage -
MermaidsSwitchboard LGBT+ provides a one -stop listening service for LGBT+ people on the
phone, by email and through instant messaging Homepage | SwitchboardThe LGBT Foundation is a national charity offering information, advice, and support
services, including a Talking Therapies Programme. LGBT Foundation – A national
charity with LGBTQ+ health and wellbeing at the heart of everything we do.”Gwent Police Chief Officer Support Team have also shared updates from the National
Police Chiefs Council and national policing LGBT+ network with Chief Officers, the
EDI manager and staff network leads: these are not Gwent Police documents to share
so we cannot provide a copy of these . Please find Section 40 (2) applied below in
relation to these external documents.Section 40(2) Personal Information – Third party information
The exemption applicable to the information you have requested for this question can
be found at Section 40(2) Personal Information, of the Act and this refusal notice is
issued under Section 17.
Gwent Police is withholding the information you have requested on the basis that the
exemption contained in s 40(2) of the Freedom of Information Act applies in that the
information you have requested is personal data of third parties and the disclosure of
the data would breach one of the principles contained in the Data Protection Act. The
relevant principle is the first principle which states that:Personal data shall be processed fairly and lawfully and in particular shall not be
processed unless –(a) at least one of the conditions in Schedule 2 is met and
(b) in the case of sensitive personal data, at least one of the conditions in Schedule 3
is metIt is only necessary to consider (a) in respect of the information requested. The
relevant condition in Schedule 2 is condition 6 which states that:"The processing is necessary for the purposes of legitimate interests pursued by the
data controller or by the third party or parties to whom the data are disclosed, except
where the processing is unwarranted in any particular case by reason of prejudice t o
the rights and freedoms or legitimate interests of the data subject"2. Has your force changed or is it considering changing its policies on use of
toilets/changing rooms for transgender people? If so, please provide detailsNo. Gwent Police has not changed its policies on use of toilets / changing rooms by
transgender people. Gwent Police await guidance from the National Police Chiefs
Council and statutory guidance from Government on the use of toilets, changing rooms
and other facilities.An update to all Chief Constables was recently circulated, which included that the
NPCC are continuing to consider other policies and practices following the Supreme
Court decision, such as the provision of toilets and changing rooms. We have attached
a copy of that guidance for awareness, which all forces will have received. We have
been advised this is suitable to share.3. Has your force changed or is it considering changing its policy on search of
detainees/suspects by transgender officers/staff? If so, please provide
detailsNo. As with the above question, Gwent Police await national guidance from the NPCC
on search policy, both for searching transgender members of the public and for the
conduct of searches by transgender officers.There has since been published guidance as well as the update attached for Question
2. Please use the following link to this published guidance - Police search guidance
following Supreme Court decision.4. Has your force held any meetings with external LGBT+ groups or internal
LGBT+ staff networks since the ruling? If so, please provide details of the
groups attending and the minutes of the meetingYes. Details of meetings are noted below under the headings of internal and external
meetings.Internal meetings:
The national police LGBT+ network has held regular meetings which officers and staff
from Gwent LGBT+ network have been invited to attend. These meetings provide
support for officers and staff who identify as lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender or
non-binary. The minutes of these meetings are confidential.The Chief Constable met with the LGBT+ network chair and EDI manager to discuss
the impact on officers and staff of the ruling. The minutes of this meeting are
confidential.The exemption applicable to the information you have requested can be found at
Section 36(2)(b)(c), of the Act and this refusal notice is issued under Section 17.Section 36(2)(b)(c)- prejudice to the effective conduct of public affairs
Section 36 provides that information is exempt from disclosure if it would or would be
likely to, inhibit the free and frank exchange of views or provision of advice for the
purposes of deliberation or otherwise prejudice the conduct of public affairs.The information in the documents relates to on -going projects which remain work in
progress of which final details still need to be further deliberated and considered.Disclosure of the information in these documents is likely to inhibit the willingness of
those who have been involved in these projects to freely and frankly submit their views
or give advice. This may have a negative impact on the quality of discussion a nd
analysis which the group relies upon to make fully informed decisions. Disclosure
would be likely to impair the quality of decision making by the Group in relation to on-
going projects.Some of the information includes live issues which have yet to be settled with views
and recommendations about matters which are not yet in the public domain or have
yet to be decided.Furthermore, disclosure might prejudice the conduct of public affairs by compromising
the safe space in which the group can discuss items of a sensitive nature at a formative
stage and as a result the quality of discussion may be limited.Section 36(2)(b)(c)- considerations favouring disclosure
Gwent Police recognises that public authorities should be transparent and open in
their conduct of the public functions but there is also a public interestSection 36(2)(b)(c)- considerations favouring non-disclosure
As disclosure of the information is likely to inhibit the on-going expression of views and
provision of advice in relation to ongoing risks. Gwent Police has decided that the
public interest in disclosure is outweighed by the need to safeguard the free and frank
discussion and provision of advice and the need to provide the safe space in which
the Group can openly discuss live and sensitive issues.External meetings:
Please note, external names have been removed and Section 40(2) Personal
Information – Third party information (provided above) will also apply.On 2 May 2025 Gwent Police held the quarterly Independent Advisory Group meeting
during which the Supreme Court ruling was discussed. The relevant meeting minutes
are provided below.The Chief Constable and Police and Crime Commissioner addressed concerns about
the recent Supreme Court ruling, reaffirming their commitment to inclusivity and
support for all communities. The Chief Constable explained that they had met with
staff network chairs and the EDI manager to hear officer, and staff concerns regarding
the ruling. They explained that they had directed the Estates team to ensure gender
neutral toilets are provided at a number of police stations. They explained that Gwent
Police will await national guidance before making any change to policies or procedures
relating to facilities and searches. An action was set for the EDI manager to meet with
the local LGBT+ community to provide information and reassurance of Gwent Police’s
commitment to inclusivity and support for all communities.On 15 May 2025 Gwent Police held a Community Tensions Group with key external
stakeholders including members of the LGBT+ community. The Supreme Court ruling
was one of the subjects under discussion. The relevant meeting minutes are provided
below:The Chair (EDI manager) explained the UK Supreme Court ruling that sex under the
Equality Act means biological sex as assigned at birth , and the impact this may have
on trans communities, officers and staff. There were two key areas identified, the first
related to the use of facilities such as toilets, changing rooms, and secondly around
search powers for police officers, i.e. Stop and Search, searches in custody.The Chair and senior policing colleagues discussed the impact of the UK Supreme
Court ruling on the legal definition of sex under the Equality Act, particularly on trans
communities and police procedures. They emphasised the need for national guidance
and the importance of supporting officers and staff.Police Procedures - The Chair stated that Gwent Police will be following the
advice/guidance of the National Police Chiefs Council. The Chair and senior policing
colleagues discussed the need for national guidance to ensure consistency across
police forces.Support for Staff - The Chair highlighted the actions taken internally to provide
support, such as the LGBT+ Network Chair and the EDI manager meeting with the
Chief Officer Team around the concerns that groups have, and how officers and staff
can be safely supported to use t he facilities with dignity and appropriateness. They
mentioned ongoing consultations with the National LGBT Network and the National
Gender Equality Network to address concerns and ensure appropriate support.Community Feedback on Supreme Court Ruling – LGBT+ community members
expressed concerns about the ruling, highlighting the fear and potential increase in
hate crimes within the trans community. They emphasi sed the need for clear
communication and support from the police and other institutions.One member expressed significant concerns about the Supreme Court ruling,
highlighting the fear and distress it has caused within the trans community. They
emphasised the potential for increased hate crimes and the need for clear
communication and support from the police. They also mentioned an upcomingdemonstration for trans rights organised by Pride in the Port outside Newport Central
police station. They stressed the importance of a low -key police presence to avoid
escalating tensions.Another member discussed the Equality and Human Rights Commission's (EHRC)
consultation on the ruling, set to launch on 19th May. They emphasised the need for
community groups to respond and the importance of clear and consistent messaging
from the police to prevent misunderstandings and potential conflicts.A senior officer explained, in answer to community concerns raised, that using the
facilities of one’s lived gender identity rather than one’s sex assigned at birth is not a
criminal offence. They explained that police might be called should a public order
situation arise, but that use of single sex facilities is not an offence.Monitoring Hate Crimes – The Senior Crime and Intelligence Analyst provided an
update on hate crime figures, noting that there has been no significant increase since
the Supreme Court ruling. They emphasised the importance of monitoring trends and
ensuring accurate reporting.Please note, every effort is made to ensure that the date presented is accurate and
complete.Freedom of Information Act is a public disclosure regime, not a private regime. Any
information disclosed under the Act is thereafter deemed to be in the public domain,
and therefore freely available to the public and will be published on the Gwent Police
website.If, upon receiving a response to a freedom of information request, you are unhappy
with the outcome, you may request an internal review. This should be made within
40 working days of the initial response.Please direct any internal review requests to [removed by PoliceFOI]
You have the right to request an appeal from the Information Commissioners Office
about your Freedom of Information request, if you are dissatisfied with your internal
review response.ICO Contact Details:
The Information Commissioner’s Office, Wycliffe House, Wilmslow, Cheshire, SK9
5AFTel: [removed by PoliceFOI]
Web: www.ico.org.uk
Thank you for your interest in Gwent Police.
- File PDF, 206 KB
The original
The text of this file
Chief Officers
Via Chiefsnet:22nd May 2025
Dear [requester],
Interim Transgender Search Guidance
Police chiefs have been reviewing the implications of last month’s UK Supreme Court judgment in
relation to the scope of the Equality Act on sex and gender.We respect the ruling of the Supreme Court and are working to implement this across policing in a
consistent manner. We also want to ensure this can be applied pragmatically across many aspects of our
service.We have put together a national coordination group looking at the impact of the ruling on policing. We
are working at pace to deliver interim solutions, while we consider its full implications.Our immediate focus has been on providing updated guidance for transgender search policies, single sex
spaces as well as the protected characteristics data standards.I am writing to share an update about the draft interim guidance on searches of members of the
transgender community, as well as searches carried out by transgender police officers, which the
National Police Chiefs’ Council will be publishing today (Thursday).It makes clear that more thorough police searches, such as those which expose intimate body parts,
should be carried out by police officers and staff of the same biological sex as the detained person.The guidance sets out where very limited exceptions can be requested by the transgender community
where they ask to be searched by someone of their lived gender. Police will endeavour to accommodate
such requests where this is operationally viable.Our aim is to ensure we are implementing the law in a pragmatic and consistent way that treats people
with fairness, dignity and respect.This guidance is based on legal advice and reflects working practice which already happens every day
across policing, where officers and detainees make requests about searches for a multitude of reasons.The guidance is explicit that any search not conducted in line with biological sex must have the written
consent of the detainee, the officer carrying out the search as well as the authorising officer.
It has been circulated to every police force in the UK. While forces are operationally independent and
make their own decisions about policy, we anticipate the guidance will be adopted by every force in
England and Wales.Searches will always be carried out where it is operationally necessary – this guidance is only intended
to apply to how these searches are conducted in the context of members of the transgender
community.This is a complex and sensitive area of policing which will greatly benefit from a clear national position
and guidance.We have moved at pace to develop this interim guidance, as it is important that officers and staff have
guidance on how searches should be conducted in light of the Supreme Court judgment.We are continuing to encourage the Home Office to consider the impact of the Supreme Court decision
on legislation and help ensure there is consistency and clarity for policing and our partners.We understand the depth of feeling there is on these issues, both among transgender communities as
well as those who hold gender critical views.Policing remains committed to serving all members of the public with fairness, dignity and respect.
In the coming weeks the NPCC will be leading an internal community impact assessment to understand
the reaction to and impact of the Supreme Court decision across policing.Chief officers are considering other policies and practices following the Supreme Court decision, such as
the provision of toilets and changing rooms.The College of Policing and NPCC are also reviewing protected characteristics data standards, working
alongside the likes of the Office for National Statistics as well as the Office for Statistics Regulation.Thank you and please reach out to ourselves or the team with any questions.
Yours sincerely
Gavin Stephens QPM
Gavin Stephens QPM
Chair National Police Chiefs’
CouncilRachel Swann QPM
Chief Constable
Derbyshire Constabulary
Chair of the NPCC Diversity,
Equality and Inclusion
Coordination Committee
Vanessa JardineChief Constable
Northumbria Police
NPCC LGBTQ+ Lead
© Gwent Police. Reproduced for non-commercial purposes from https://www.gwent.police.uk/foi-ai/gwent-police/disclosure2/2025/202528531---supreme-court-ruling/ under Gwent Police's publication scheme terms, which allow free reproduction if accurate and not misleading, with the source and copyright acknowledged. The text only, as read from the published documents; material owned by others is not covered. Collected on 2 September 2026; Gwent Police may have changed or withdrawn it since.
If this text names you or you own part of it, ask us to take the full text down: it is hidden as soon as you send the form, and the title and summary stay.
Related releases
- Accelerated Misconduct Hearing Former PC 1801 Paul Chadwick Misconduct hearing notice · Gwent Police · 8 Sept 2026
- Misconduct Hearing PC 2366 Jonathan Graham Misconduct hearing notice · Gwent Police · 7 Sept 2026
- 2026/29507 - Trauma Informed Training Disclosure log response · Gwent Police · 1 Jul 2026
- 2025/28996 - Enforcement of parking offences Disclosure log response · Gwent Police · 27 Mar 2026
- 2025/29012 - Phone Theft 2024-25 Disclosure log response · Gwent Police · 27 Mar 2026
Ask us to remove a name from this page (free) · Report a mistake