FOI 22875 Internal Review of FOI 22868Disclosure log response · Staffordshire Police
FOI 22875 Internal Review of FOI 22868
Read it at Staffordshire Police's website
- Published
- 13 May 2026
- Published by
- Staffordshire Police
- Outcome
- Refused
- Exemption
- Section 12 Cost limit: finding the information would cost more than the limit (£450 for the police)
- Source
- Staffordshire Police's website
- Recorded by PoliceFOI
- 2 Sept 2026
We read the outcome and the exemption automatically from the response's own words, so this can be wrong: report a mistake. What the outcomes and codes mean.
In full, as Staffordshire Police published it
We show a record in full only where its publisher's terms allow it. Most police forces in England and Wales publish under the same publication scheme terms: anyone may reproduce a force's own material free of charge if it is accurate and not misleading and the source and copyright are acknowledged, but not for any commercial purpose. PoliceFOI is published by a company, so we treat our use as commercial, and for those forces we show each record's title and summary, with a link to the original, until the force agrees to more. A few forces' terms are stricter still. None of these terms covers material owned by someone else, or a force's logo, so we link to such material rather than copy it.
Files
- File PDF, 197 KB
The original
The text of this file
Internal Review
Re: Request for internal review of response to application for information under the provisions of
the Freedom of Information Act 2000, original request first notified to Staffordshire Police o n
11/05/2026SP refer to the above request which was expressed in the following terms:
I am writing to request information under the Freedom of Information Act 2000. Please disclose:
In your police force area, how many incidents of "Asian gold theft" have taken place in each of the
calendar years, 2021, 2022, 2023, 2024 and 2025.To clarify: "Asian gold theft" is the theft of gold from Asian families. Criminals are targeting Asian families
knowing that many have gold, for cultural reasons. If you are unable to narrow the results down
specifically to Asian families, I would also accept the number of thefts of gold from domestic properties.Further to the above, SP also note the following comments made within your request for Internal
Review.While I acknowledge the force’s position that compliance would exceed the cost limit under section 12(1)
of the Freedom of Information Act 2000, I would ask that this decision be reconsidered for the following
reasons.1. Precedent
Substantially similar requests concerning incidents of so called “Asian gold theft”, or thefts of gold from
domestic properties, have been disclosed by other police forces under the Freedom of Information Act.
For example: Devon & Cornwall Police, Dorset Police & Northamptonshire Police. These forces are among
a large number who have released similar data.In those cases, forces have been able to identify relevant offences either through keyword searches,
offence descriptions, property type filtering, or existing crime classifications, without conducting a manual
review of every theft, burglary or robbery re cord. This suggests that comparable data is, in practice,
retrievable within the statutory cost limits, or at least partially retrievable.Our Ref: FOI 22875
Your Ref: FOI 22868
Date: 12 May 20262. Section 16
I am concerned that the duty to provide advice and assistance under section 16 of the Act has not been
fully met. The refusal notice states that Staffordshire Police is unable to suggest any way in which the
request could be refined or narrowed. However, other forces have successfully responded to this type of
request by:• Limiting results to offences recorded as burglaries or dwelling related thefts
• Using keyword searches within MO, property descriptions, or free text fields
• Supplying partial data or aggregate figures where more granular analysis was not possible
I would therefore ask that, as part of the internal review, consideration be given to whether similar
approaches could be applied here, or whether a revised or partial disclosure could be made that would fall
within the cost threshold.3. Public Interest
Third, I would note the strong public interest in transparency around crime trends affecting specific
communities. The request relates to an emerging and widely reported pattern of offending, and disclosure
of high level data would assist informed public d ebate and understanding, even if the information could
not be provided with absolute precision.SP Response
Upon review of your request for information under the Freedom of Information provision
referenced above and all corresponding communication, we are of the opinion that the
response issued, alongside all clarification provided, fully answers the terms of yo ur
request.We also confirm that the application of the exemption cited within this response is fully
justified, and that the explanation and rationale for its application conveyed clearly and
unequivocally.However, in order to address the concerns raised within your request for internal review,
please find below some further expansion upon our approach and rationale for the initial
response.1. Precedent
We note your concerns regarding the precedent set by other forces; however, it is of
importance to note that differing forces use different crime recording systems and
extraction tools. Furthermore, configuration of these systems and tools can vary from
force to force. This will mean that, whilst it may be mandatory to record certain information
within one force, this may not be recordable or even mandatory to record within another.
Likewise, extraction methods employed within any given force will differ to those of
another. This will mean that the level and variety of data providable by one force will very
often not be replicated in another.We also note your comments regarding the employment of key word searches; however,
these are inherently inaccurate as they rely on exact phrase /s being employed within a
specific field of the crime report. Whilst this information would most likely be recorded
within the Modus Operandi (MO) field, it is worth noting that completion of this field is not
a mandatory requirement within our crime recording system and the information could
therefore be recorded across any number of other similar fields. As previo usly outlined,
manual research of all fields would be required in order to determine those occurrences
falling within the scope of your request.
Additionally, there is no mandatory field within this system in which details of stolen items
is routi nely recorded, this may be recorded ac ross any number of fields across the
occurrence log.
Having reviewed the reports used to access the relevant data for this request, SP note that
some 2000 plus MO fields remain blank.
Using the formula outlined within our initial response, namely 3 minutes to review each
record, research of these occurrences alone would require upwards of 100 hours to
determine whether they fall within the scope of your request.2. Section 16
Given the limitations outlined above, SP feels that the initial advi ce stands, in that no
advice can be offered to assist you to refine your request to allow it to fall within the time
and cost threshold prescribed by the act.3. Public Interest
Whilst SP recognise the strong public interest in transparency around trends in crime and
offending, in this instance the limitations created by idiosyncrasies in our crime recording
and reporting tools mean that extraction of the specific information requested has not
been possible.Please be advised that all FOI requests and response letters are published on the Staffordshire Police
website although personal details are not included.If you are not content with the outcome of the review, you may apply directly to the Information
Commissioner to investigate. The Information Commissioner can be contacted at:
https://ico.org.uk/make-a-complaint/foi-and-eir-complaints/foi-and-eir-complaints/Information Access Team Management
[removed by PoliceFOI]
© Staffordshire Police. Reproduced for non-commercial purposes from https://www.staffordshire.police.uk/SysSiteAssets/foi-media/staffordshire/2026-published-foi-requests/may/foi-22875-internal-review-of-foi-22868.pdf under Staffordshire Police's publication scheme terms, which allow free reproduction if accurate and not misleading, with the source and copyright acknowledged. The text only, as read from the published documents; material owned by others is not covered. Collected on 2 September 2026; Staffordshire Police may have changed or withdrawn it since.
If this text names you or you own part of it, ask us to take the full text down: it is hidden as soon as you send the form, and the title and summary stay.
Related releases
- Accelerated misconduct hearing for PC Alex Potts Misconduct hearing notice · Staffordshire Police · 21 Sept 2026
- FOI 23366 Shotgun Certificates Disclosure log response · Staffordshire Police · 21 Sept 2026
- FOI 23389 Published News Content Disclosure log response · Staffordshire Police · 21 Sept 2026
- FOI 23393 Speed Camera Van Disclosure log response · Staffordshire Police · 21 Sept 2026
- FOI 23396 Sickness Levels Disclosure log response · Staffordshire Police · 21 Sept 2026
Ask us to remove a name from this page (free) · Report a mistake