FOI 23045 IR of 23005 Major Crime ReviewDisclosure log response · Staffordshire Police
FOI 23045 IR of 23005 Major Crime Review
Read it at Staffordshire Police's website
- Published
- 8 Jul 2026
- Published by
- Staffordshire Police
- Source
- Staffordshire Police's website
- Recorded by PoliceFOI
- 2 Sept 2026
In full, as Staffordshire Police published it
We show a record in full only where its publisher's terms allow it. Most police forces in England and Wales publish under the same publication scheme terms: anyone may reproduce a force's own material free of charge if it is accurate and not misleading and the source and copyright are acknowledged, but not for any commercial purpose. PoliceFOI is published by a company, so we treat our use as commercial, and for those forces we show each record's title and summary, with a link to the original, until the force agrees to more. A few forces' terms are stricter still. None of these terms covers material owned by someone else, or a force's logo, so we link to such material rather than copy it.
Files
- File PDF, 261 KB
The original
The text of this file
Internal Review
Re: Request for internal review of response to application for information under the provisions of
the Freedom of Information Act 2000, original request first notified to Staffordshire Police o n
12/06/2026.SP refer to the above request which was expressed in the following terms:
I am requesting access to the formal case closure reports, internal review summaries, or policy decision
logs held by the Major Crime Review Team regarding the 2020 decision to terminate the reopened
investigation into the 2002 murder of Kevin Nunes.Context:
In 2020, it was publicly disclosed that the reopened investigation into the homicide of Kevin Nunes had
concluded without charges. The Crown Prosecution Service formally declined to bring an indictment,
citing that historic investigative failings and witness-handling issues from the original 2002 investigation
meant that any contemporary prosecution would constitute an "abuse of the legal process."Specific Information Requested:
The formal internal case closure report, briefing note, or decision log generated by Staffordshire Police in
2019 or 2020 detailing the final administrative rationale for halting the active murder investigation.Records or internal correspondence held within this closure file detailing the specific historic police
handling failures from the original investigation that met the legal threshold for an "Abuse of Process,"
thereby preventing a criminal indictment from being brought against the identified chief suspect.Further to the above, SP also note the following comments made within your request for Internal
Review.
I am writing to formally request an independent Internal Review of Staffordshire Police’s
decision, dated 23 June 2026, to withhold the information requested under reference 23005.
The force has applied a blanket exemption under Section 30(1)(a)(b) (Criminal Investigations). I
am dissatisfied with this outcome as I believe the Public Interest Balance Test has been applied
incorrectly and fails to reflect the unique legal status of this historic case.
Grounds for Review:
1. Erroneous Application of Prejudice to "Future Investigations"
Our Ref: FOI 23045
Your Ref: FOI 23005
Date: 08 July 2026The refusal notice states that disclosure could “risk interference with evidence, which could
have detrimental impact on future investigations... and the right to a fair trial.” This rationale is
factually flawed.
In 2020, the Crown Prosecution Service formally declined to bring any indictments and closed
the reopened Nunes investigation permanently, explicitly stating that historic police mishandling
meant any contemporary prosecution would constitute an unappealable Abuse of Process.
Because an Abuse of Process ruling creates a permanent, structural bar to prosecution, there
are no active, viable, or planned "future investigations" or "trials" that could be prejudiced by this
disclosure.
2. High-Level Historical Misconduct and the Public Interest The systemic handling failures
associated with the original 2002 Kevin Nunes investigation, including the Sensitive Policing
Unit's contamination of the primary witness, have already been heavily detailed in the public
domain via the Court of Appeal judgment R v Adam Joof & Ors [2012] EWCA Crim 1475 and
the unsealing of the 2007 Costello Report findings.
The public interest heavily favours understanding how Staffordshire Police administratively
reconciled these historic, judicially criticized failings to bring the case to its definitive 2020
closure.
Revealing the administrative rationale for terminating a multi-million-pound, publicly funded
historic murder matrix does not hinder law enforcement; it fulfills the core purpose of the FOIA
regarding institutional accountability.
Conclusion:
I accept that operational tactical methodologies can be redacted.
However, I request that the independent supervisor re-evaluate the balance test and release a
redacted copy of the 2019/2020 case closure report and final administrative decision logs.
SP ResponseAn Internal Review has been completed, and SP now wish to provide a revised response;
please disr egard the original response (23005) wh ere a s30 (Criminal Inves tigations)
exemption was cited.The revised response is as follows:
The formal internal case closure report, briefing note, or decision log generated by Staffordshire
Police in 2019 or 2020 detailing the final administrative rationale for halting the active murder
investigation.
No information is held; the review is ongoing and the case is not closed.Records or internal correspondence held within this closure file detailing the specific historic
police handling failures from the original investigation that met the legal threshold for an "Abuse
of Process," thereby preventing a criminal indictment from being brought against the identified
chief suspect.
No information is held as there is no such file,Please be advised that all FOI requests and response letters are published on the Staffordshire
Police website although personal details are not included.If you are not content with the outcome of the review, you may apply directly to the Information
Commissioner to investigate. The Information Commissioner can be contacted at:
https://ico.org.uk/make-a-complaint/foi-and-eir-complaints/foi-and-eir-complaints/Information Access Team Management
[removed by PoliceFOI]
© Staffordshire Police. Reproduced for non-commercial purposes from https://www.staffordshire.police.uk/SysSiteAssets/foi-media/staffordshire/2026-published-foi-requests/july/foi-23045-ir-of-23005-major-crime-review.pdf under Staffordshire Police's publication scheme terms, which allow free reproduction if accurate and not misleading, with the source and copyright acknowledged. The text only, as read from the published documents; material owned by others is not covered. Collected on 2 September 2026; Staffordshire Police may have changed or withdrawn it since.
If this text names you or you own part of it, ask us to take the full text down: it is hidden as soon as you send the form, and the title and summary stay.
Related releases
- Accelerated misconduct hearing for PC Alex Potts Misconduct hearing notice · Staffordshire Police · 21 Sept 2026
- FOI 23366 Shotgun Certificates Disclosure log response · Staffordshire Police · 21 Sept 2026
- FOI 23389 Published News Content Disclosure log response · Staffordshire Police · 21 Sept 2026
- FOI 23393 Speed Camera Van Disclosure log response · Staffordshire Police · 21 Sept 2026
- FOI 23396 Sickness Levels Disclosure log response · Staffordshire Police · 21 Sept 2026
Ask us to remove a name from this page (free) · Report a mistake