FOI 23088 HRD 08 UPAP GUIDANCE Final Oct13Disclosure log response · Staffordshire Police
FOI 23088 HRD 08 UPAP Guidance Final Oct13
Read it at Staffordshire Police's website
- Published
- 5 Aug 2026
- Published by
- Staffordshire Police
- Source
- Staffordshire Police's website
- Recorded by PoliceFOI
- 2 Sept 2026
In full, as Staffordshire Police published it
We show a record in full only where its publisher's terms allow it. Most police forces in England and Wales publish under the same publication scheme terms: anyone may reproduce a force's own material free of charge if it is accurate and not misleading and the source and copyright are acknowledged, but not for any commercial purpose. PoliceFOI is published by a company, so we treat our use as commercial, and for those forces we show each record's title and summary, with a link to the original, until the force agrees to more. A few forces' terms are stricter still. None of these terms covers material owned by someone else, or a force's logo, so we link to such material rather than copy it.
Files
- File PDF, 821 KB
The original
The text of this file
HRD 8
Oct 13 V4.0
NOT PROTECTIVELY MARKEDUnsatisfactory Performance and Attendance – Police Officers
1.0 Introduction
2.0 General Principles and Definitions of Unsatisfactory Performance/
Attendance
3.0 Unsatisfactory Performance and Complaints
4.0 Link between Unsatisfactory Performance/Attendance and Misconduct5.0 Standards of Professional Behaviour
6.0 Continuous Professional Development (CPD)
7.0 Overview of U.P.A.P. Process
8.0 Informal Management Action prior to Formal Procedures (Informal Stages)
9.0 Stages (Formal Procedures)
10.0 Formal Procedure
11.0 Assessment of Performance/Attendance – Improvement Review Meeting
12.0 Stage 2 Meeting
13.0 Gross Incompetence
14.0 Stage 3 Meeting
15.0 Stage 3 Meeting Administration
16.0 Role and Responsibilities
17.0 The Appeals Procedure
Forms: Access Forms Database Here
UPAP 1 Notice of Stage 1 Meeting Letter to Officer
UPAP 2 Notice of Outcome(s) following Stage 1 Meeting to OfficerUPAP 3 Stage 1 End of Monitoring Period – Satisfactory Performance/Attendance Letter to Officer
UPAP 4 Notice of Stage 2 Meeting Letter to Officer
UPAP 5 Notice of Outcome(s) following Stage 2 Meeting to OfficerUPAP 6 Stage 2 End of Monitoring Period – Satisfactory Performance/Attendance Letter to Officer
UPAP 7 Notice of Stage 3 Meeting (following 1 & 2) Letter to Officer
UPAP 8 Notice of Stage 3 Meeting (Gross Incompetence) Letter to OfficerUPAP 9 Notice of Outcome(s) following Stage 3 Meeting to Officer- Issue/ Extension to Final Written Improvement Notice (F.W.I.N.).
UPAP 10 Written Improvement Notice
UPAP 11 Action Plan
UPAP 12 Progress FormProduced by Staffordshire Police
for FOI 23088HRD 8
Oct 13 V4.0
NOT PROTECTIVELY MARKED1.0 Introduction
The performance of individual Police Officers is a key element in the delivery of a quality
Policing Service.Performance and attendance management in the P olice service are intended to be
positive and supportive processes, with the aim being to im prove performance or
attendance. However, there will be cases w here formal action under this procedure
and related procedures is required to improve performance and/or attendance This
procedure outlines Staffordshire Poli ce’s approa ch to dealing with unsatisfac tory
performance/attendance of P olice Officer s. T he related procedur es assist managers to
decide how and when to use the formal procedures contained within the Poli ce
(Performance) Regulations 2012 and the Staffordshire Police Unsatisfactory Performance
and Attendance Management Procedure.The underlying principle of the procedures is to provide a fair, open and proportionate
method of dealing with the performance and attendance issues and to encourage a
culture of learning and development for individuals and the organisation.Application (Performance Regulations only)
This procedure applies to Police Officers up to and including the r ank of Chief
Superintendent and Special Constables. However, given the nature of Special C onstables
as unpaid volunteers, cases where the procedures are initiated for S pecial Constables
may be limited to those where the S pecial Constab e either contests that his or her
performance is unsatisfactory or agrees that it is unsatisfactory but expresses a desi re to
continue with his or her Special Constable duties.Student Officers (Performance Regulations only)
The procedure and re at ed procedures do n ot apply to Student Officers during their
probationary period. There is a separate pr ocedure for Student Officer s which is
underpinned by Regulation 13 of the Police Regulations 2003.2.0 General Principles and Definitions of Unsatisfactory Performance / Attendance
The primary aim of this procedure is to provide positive support to im prove performance
and attendance in the Police service. It i s envisaged that early intervent ion via
management action should achieve the desired effect of improving and maintaining a n
Officer’s performance or attendance to an acceptable level in a timely manner.There will, however, be cases where it will be approp riate for managers to take form al
action under the procedures. Where perfor mance or attendance does not improve to
acceptable levels or, in the case of attendance, where there is no r ealistic prospect of
return to work in a reasonable timeframe, this may lead to dismissal.Produced by Staffordshire Police
for FOI 23088HRD 8
Oct 13 V4.0
NOT PROTECTIVELY MARKEDThis Procedure is based on the following principles:
All unsatisfactory performance/attendance matters should be dealt with fairly, at an
appropriate level and with minimum delay.Where unsatisfactory performance/attendance procedures are used, managers and other
stakeholders involved in the process must a ct in a way which an obj ective observer would
consider reasonable. These include:• Ensuring the Officer is clear as to the breach of the relevant procedures, this should be
based on facts;• Discussing any shortcoming (s) or concern (s) with the officer at the earliest
possible opportunity;• Establishing whether there are any underlying r easons for unsatisfactory
performance/attendance issue. This will include health issues and other factors which
may or may not be within the scope of equality legislation;• Providing support and guidance where appropriate
• Ensuring t hat the level of any outcome imposed and any related remedial action,
taking into account all the circumstances is proportionate, consistent and fair in the
circumstances;• Dealing with issues sensitively and appropriately
• Conducting the procedures in accordance with this procedure and r elated
procedures which are underpinned by the Performance Regulations;Individual officers have the right to appeal against the outcome at each stage
of the procedures.2.1 Legal Representation
An officer may seek legal adv ice at any time, although legal representation is confined to
third stage meetings where the procedure has been initiated at this stage due to alleged
gross incompetence. Advice can also be sought from staff associations and all o fficers
can be advised and represented by a Police friend.2.2 Gross incompetence
Gross incompetence is defined in Regulation 4 of the Police (Performance) Regulations
2012 as:‘ …a serious inability or failure of a Police Officer to perform the duties of the role
or rank he/she is currently undertaking to a satisfactory standard or level, to the
extent that di smissal would be justified, e xcept that no account shall be taken of
the attendance of a Police Officer when considering whe ther he has been grossly
incompetent.’Produced by Staffordshire Police
for FOI 23088HRD 8
Oct 13 V4.0
NOT PROTECTIVELY MARKED2.3 Unsatisfactory Performance
The procedure and related procedure are designed to cover either repeated failures to
meet satisfactory standards or more serious ca ses of unsatisfactory
performance/capability. Occasional lapses below satisfactory standar ds should be dealt
with in the course of normal day to day management activity.Unsatisfactory Performance or Attendance is defined in Regulation 4 of the Police
(Performance) Regulations 2012 as:‘An inability or failure of a Police Officer to perform the duties of the role or rank
he/she is currently undertaking to a satisfactory standard or level’.2.4 Unsatisfactory Attendance
The procedure when used in conjunction with the F orce Sickness Absen ce Policy is
designed to deal with matters relating to periods of absence, which com promise an
officer’s ability to perform their duties. A failure by a Police Officer to co-operate will
not prevent formal action being taken or continued. This procedure and related
procedure(s) should be utilised in cases of both unacceptable levels of persistent short-
term absences and long-term absences due to sickness and/or injury.3.0 Unsatisfactory Performance and Complaints
There may be instances where line managers are made aware of unsatisfactory
performance on the part of one of their o fficers as a result of information from a member
of the public. This may take the form of an official complaint. Such cases will be dealt with
in accordance with the force proc edures for handling complaints and will be largely
overseen by the Performance Assessment Unit within People Services.In cases where the outcome of a local resolution or an investigation into a complaint is
that of unsatisfactory performance it may be appropriate to invoke these procedures in
order to improve the performance of the o fficer and provide them wi th an opportunity to
learn and adjust their behaviour.It may also be the case that a complaint adds to existing indications of an o fficer’s
unsatisfactory performance to the extent that action under this procedure is appropriate
or, if the o fficer is already subject to proceedings, continuation to the next stage of the
process may be required.The Performance Assessment Unit will advise line managers of the required intervention
to address performance issues which have been highlighted as a result of a complaint or
anti corruption activity.The process for the management of complaints can be accessed via the Force Policy
Database – Police (Conduct) Regulations, Appendix B.Produced by Staffordshire Police
for FOI 23088HRD 8
Oct 13 V4.0
NOT PROTECTIVELY MARKED4.0 Link between Unsatisfactory Performance/Attendance and Misconduct
In most cases, unsatisfactory performance will be apparent to a line manager and should
be addressed through management action and a performance plan accordingly. However,
in some cases it may not be apparent whether the matter is one of misconduct or
unsatisfactory performance. This should be established as soon as possible so that the
most appropriate procedure can be followed.In cases of alleged misconduct, the issue must be referred to the designated Ch ief
Inspector/Senior Police Staff Manager who should liaise with a HR Representative in order to
agree the most appropriate course of action.Misconduct is defined as a breach of the Standards of Professional Behaviour:
• Honesty and Integrity
• Authority, Respect and Courtesy
• Equality and Diversity
• Use of Force
• Orders and Instructions
• Duties and Responsibilities
Produced by Staffordshire Police
for FOI 23088HRD 8
Oct 13 V4.0
NOT PROTECTIVELY MARKED• Confidentiality
• Fitness for Duty
• Discreditable Conduct
• Challenging and Reporting Improper ConductGross Misconduct is defined as a breach of the Standards of Pr ofessional Behaviour
so serious that dismissal would be justified.In some cases there may be a breach of both misconduct and performance procedures
and therefore each will be dealt with under the respective procedures.Documentation gathered under unsatisfactory performance procedures may be used for
the purposes of the misconduct procedure. H owever, if criminal proceedings are in place
to investigate the alleged misconduct, evidence may need to be gathered under caution
and therefore it may not prove possible to use documentation regarding the performance
issue(s). In these circumstances, advice shou ld be sought from th e Performance
Assessment Unit.4.1 Link between Unsatisfactory Performance and Attendance
Attendance management in the P olice service is intended to be a positive and supportive
process to improve sickness attendance. Where line managers are providing supportive
action in order to improve the attendance of an officer they may also identify areas of
unsatisfactory performance as it is recognised that both unsatisfactory performance and
unsatisfactory attendance can be linked.Where it is identified that an individual has both performance and attendance issues,
they must be managed separately . Line managers should ensure that there is both a
Performance Action Plan to address the issues commensurate with performance and an
individual support plan in place to address the issues concerning the attendance at work,
both of which should be independent.In all cases, the starting point to address the unsatisfactory performance and/or
attendance is supportive action Line managers in consultation with a HR Office r, must
ensure that the appropriate supportive action is taken before formal action is instigated
under this procedure.4.2 Medical retirement under Police pension legislation (Performance Procedures)
Where an officer is referred to the Selected Medical Practitioner (SMP) for consideration
of permanent disablement under the Poli ce Pensions Regulations, any action under this
procedure and related procedure (unsatisfactory attendance) will not be finalized whilst
the question of H1 remains outstanding. The organisation reserves the right to continue
to manage the case under these procedures but no date will be set for a Stage 3 meeting
until the matter is concluded. Alternatively, action under these procedures may be
suspended until such a time as permanent disablement has been considered and the
report of the SMP h as been received. The above should also appl y where the o fficer
appeals to a Medical Appeals Board against the decision by the SMP.Action can, be taken under this procedure and related procedure where a case has been
referred or is the subject of appeal if the unsatisfactory attendance is unrelated to the
Produced by Staffordshire Police
for FOI 23088HRD 8
Oct 13 V4.0
NOT PROTECTIVELY MARKEDcondition forming the basis of the referral or appeal. Appropriate advice should be
sought from the Force Medical Advisor via the Head of People Services.5.0 Standards of Professional Behaviour
Honesty and Integrity
Police Officers are honest, act with integrity and do not compromise or abuse their
position.Authority, Respect and Courtesy
Police Officers act with self-control a nd tolerance, treating members of the public
and colleagues with respect and courtesy. Police Officer s do not abuse their powers
or authority and respect the rights of all individuals.Equality and Diversity
Police Officers act with fairness and impartiality. They do not discriminate unlawfully or
unfairly.Use of Force
Police Officers only use force to the extent that it is necessary, proportionate
and reasonable in all the circumstances.Orders and Instructions
Police Officers only give and carry out lawful orders and instructions.
Police Officers abide by police Regulations, Force Policies and Lawful Orders.Duties and Responsibilities
Police Officers are diligent in the exercise of their duties and responsibilities.Confidentiality
Police Officers treat information with respect and access or disclose it only in the
proper course of Police duties.Fitness for Duty
Police Officers when on duty or presenting themselves for duty are fit to carry out
their responsibilities.Discreditable Conduct
Police Officers behave in a manner which does not discredit the police service
or undermine public confidence, whether on or off duty.Police Officers report any action taken against them for a criminal offence, any conditions
imposed on them by a court or the receipt of any penalty notice.Challenging and Reporting Improper Conduct
Police Officers report, challenge or take action against the conduct of colleagues
which has fallen below the Standards of Professional Behaviour.Produced by Staffordshire Police
for FOI 23088HRD 8
Oct 13 V4.0
NOT PROTECTIVELY MARKED6.0 C ontinuous Professional Development (CPD)
All officers are required to maintain their standards of professional practice and take
personal responsibility to ensure that they:• Identify, implement and monitor development activities to enhance
performance.
• Assess skills and identify personal development needs at regular intervals
• Undertake continuous self-development activities
• Keep up to date with changes affecting their roleStaffordshire Police seeks to promote a self directed learning culture by helping
individuals to identify alternative development opportunities to support thei c ontinuous
professional development. Managers at all levels in the organisation are required to
support officers in meeting this requirement and encourage everyone to maintain a record
of their professional and personal development in a Continuous Professional
Development (CPD) plan.A Continuous Professional Development plan provides an o fficer with the opportunity to
record any activity which is linked to their professional and personal development. This
can be used to highlight any development that they require in their current role and will
also assist managers in providing support at an early stage in a positive and pro active
manner.For further information regarding the force CPD procedure please see HRD07 –
Performance Management and Continuous Professional Development.7.0 Overview of U.P.A.P. Process
Informal Management Action /
ASM Line Manager
Performance Action Plan/ISP
Stage One Meeting
Line ManagerW.I.N & Performance Action Plan
Stage Two Meeting
2nd Line ManagerF.W.I.N & Performance Plan
Stage Three Meeting
PanelAppeal Process
Appeal Process
Appeal Process
PAT
Produced by Staffordshire Police
for FOI 23088HRD 8
Oct 13 V4.0
NOT PROTECTIVELY MARKED8.0 Informal Management Action prior to Formal Procedures (Informal Stages)
Managers are required to deal with unsatisfactory performance or attendance issues in
light of their knowledge of the o fficer and any circumstances giving rise to concerns. It is
envisaged that early intervention via management action should achieve the desired effect
of improving and maintaining performance to an acceptable manner.Line Managers must ensure that any shortcoming(s) or concern(s) regarding the
performance or attendance are discussed with the o fficer at the earliest possible
opportunity. The reasons for the concern(s) should be made clear to the officer as soon as
possible and there should be a factual basis for initiating a discussion around his or her
performance i.e. the discussion must relate to specific incidents that have occurred and
how the required standards have not been achieved.In taking a proactive approach line managers should initially counsel the individual to
determine reasons for the unsatisfactory performance and identify ways of resolution
without recourse to the formal procedure. In doing so line managers may establish whether
there are any underlying reasons for the unsatisfactory performance or attendance. By
using early intervention it may be that the officer reveals information which could
demonstrate a lack of training or instruction for example. It is good practice for a line
manager to hold an informal meeting with the officer concerned in order to address and
discuss the performance issue(s) in an open manner concentrating on the following:• Defining the root issue/problem
• Identifying realistic and achievable standards of performance
• Discussion of the shortcomings in reaching these standards
• Exploring possible reasons for shortcomings
• Agreeing how and when acceptable performance might be achieved, with r ealistic
timescales and monitoring arrangements ( Implementation of a Performance Action
Plan).Both parties should look to suggest me hods of assisting the individual to improve, and full
account must be taken of the individual’s own circumstances. Line Managers must give the
individual every opportunity to present their explanation of the situation and should
encourage the officer to use a CPD log in order to record their development needs.Management action taken as a result of identifying unsatisfactor y performance or
attendance should be recorded by way of a performance action plan. A performance action
plan describes what action(s) the Police Officer should take to help them achieve and
maintain the required improvement and should be formulated and agreed by both parties.In particular, the performance action plan should:
• Identify any weaknesses which may be the cause o f unsatisfactory performance or
attendance;
• Outline the steps th e officer must take to improve performance and/or attendance
and what support is available from the organisation e.g. training , referral to
Occupational, Health, Safety & Welfare;
• Specify the period within which actions identified should be reviewed; and
Produced by Staffordshire Police
for FOI 23088HRD 8
Oct 13 V4.0
NOT PROTECTIVELY MARKED• Set a date(s) for a staged review(s) of the Police Officer’s performance or
attendance
• Specify a validity period (see 8.1)And should include the following:
• Training/ retraining/ development
• Referral, where appropriate, to Occupational Health Safety and Welfare
• Mentoring/ coaching
• Closer supervision for a limited period
• Temporary alterations to duties which do not change the character of the role but
allow the individual to develop at a more gradual pace.By creating a P erformance Action Plan, line managers ensure continuity in circumstances
and ensure that the discussi ons are documented. It is also important to record when
improvement has been made in the o fficer’s performance or attendance. The Performance
Action Plan should be completed using the Lotus Notes Database.Line Managers can consider individual interventions in isolation or in any combination when
agreeing the plan and are able to apply discretion to determine the appropriate use of
interventions.The period of time agreed by the line manager for the o fficer concerned to improve their
performance or attendance must be sufficient to provide a reasonable opportunity for the
desired improvement to take place however, it is not envisaged that this should exceed 3
months. This period may be extended i f, due to unforeseen circumstances (e.g. certified
sickness absence in the context of the performance ssues) the Police Officer is unable to
demonstrate whether or not the required improvement has been achieved.Consideration will be given as to whether there are any health or welfare issues that are or
may be affecting the performance or attendance of the officer. If an officer has or may have
a disability within the scope of the Equality Act (2010) this would need to be taken into
account and reasonable adjustments should be discussed to ensure that his or her
individual needs are met.In line with the Sickness Absence Procedure, individuals that have persistent short -term
absences within a 12 month rolling period or a long term sickness period (individuals who
meet the “red” rating criteria) will trigger an early management intervention. This comprises
of an Attendance Support meeting, management welfare visits and the implementation of
an Individual Support Plan. The plan is aimed at documenting the required activities that an
individual is required to comply with, providing supportive and positive measures in order
for the individual to maintain attendance at work. Line Managers and individuals must read
the detailed information upon how to compose an I ndividual Support Plan and how to
manage attendance issues under the informal process / management intervention by
reference to the Sickness Absence Policy.Ideally, as a result of management action, performance or attendance will improve to an
acceptable level. Where there is no improvement, insufficient improv ement or the
improvement is not sustained over the specified period, it will then be appropriate to
escalate the issues to the formal stages of the procedure.
Produced by Staffordshire Police
for FOI 23088HRD 8
Oct 13 V4.0
NOT PROTECTIVELY MARKED8.1 Informal Stage Validity Period
Where cases of unsatis factory performance/attendance are dealt with via management
action at an informal stage, the performance action plan will have a specified period of up
to 3 months and a validity period of 12 months from the effective date of the performance
action plan.If improvements are not achieved via the informal management action or there is a failure
to maintain the improvement within the validity period, the line manager (in consultation
with the relevant HR Officer ) will arrange a meeting with the o fficer to discuss his/her
performance and/or attendance under the formal procedures.9.0 Stages (Formal Procedures)
The point at which a concern about a Police Officer’s performance should lead to action
being taken under the formal procedures of the Police (Performance) Regulations is not
prescriptive. Each case should be considered in light of what it known as there is no
restriction on referring cases straight to a first stage meeting where the manager considers
it appropriate to do so. However, managers should be able to demonstrate that they have
considered whether management action is appropriate before using the formal stages of
the procedure.In cases where the performance of the individual officer is considered more serious and
the line manager believes that written improvement advice would be more appropriate,
consultation with a HR Officer and the Performance Assessment Unit should be
undertaken.9.1 Overview of the Formal Procedures
The formal procedures contain 3 stages with a right of appeal at each stage.
Stage Responsibility
Formal Stage 1
MeetingFirst line manager. Relevant Human Resources
representative (HRO/HRM) will attend as an advisor.
Stage 1 AppealSecond line manager. Independent HRO/HRM
will attend as an advisor.Formal Stage 2
MeetingSecond line m anager. Relevant Human Resources
representative (HRO/HRM) will attend as an advisor.
Stage 2 AppealSenior Manager. Independent HRO/HRM will
attend as an advisor.
Produced by Staffordshire Police
for FOI 23088HRD 8
Oct 13 V4.0
NOT PROTECTIVELY MARKEDFormal Stage 3
MeetingSenior Officer and 2 Panel Members. U sually;
ACPO, Superintendent and Senior HR Manager
Stage 3 AppealPolice Appeals Tribunal
Definitions (Formal Procedures)
Appropriate Authority – the Chief Officer (or nominated deputy)
Bank Holiday – a day which is a bank holiday under the Banking and Financial Dealings
Act 1971(c) in England and Wales. Consideration will also be given where an o fficer has
elected bank holidays, commensurate with the Winsor Recommendations.First Line Manager – Police Officer or Police staff individual who has immediate
supervisory responsibility of the officer e.g. SergeantInterested Party – a person whose involvement in the procedures could reasonably give
rise to a concern as to whether s/he could act impartially.Nominated Person – A Senior Manager may appoint another Police Officer/Police staff of
at least the same or equivalent rank or grade to carry out either the functions of the First
Line Manager or the Second Li ne manager; referred to as a nominated person. This may
be appropriate in circumstances wher e the l ine managers are not available during the
process to perform the function of the rolePolice Friend – Federation / Super ntendent Association Representative or Staffordshire
Police member of staff (Police Officer or Police staff).Second Li ne Manager – Police Officer or Police sta ff individual who has
immediate supervisory responsibility of the first line manager e.g. InspectorSenior Manager – Police Officer or Police staff ind ividual who has immediate
supervisory responsibility of the second line manager e.g. Chief Inspector or equivalent.Senior Officer – Police Officer holding a rank above that of Chief
Superintendent.Working Day – means any other day other than a Saturday or a Sunday, a bank holiday
or a public holiday in England and Wales.Timescales (during the Formal Procedure)
The strict timescales detailed within the procedure should be adhered to at each stage of
the procedure under normal circumstances. There may, however, be circumstances which
necessitate an extension to these timescales (e.g. availability of Senior Officers or
equivalent) and it is expected that all parties will operate a common sense approach
towards mutually ag reeing to extend timescales. Where an exten sion is agreed, this will
be confirmed in writing by the relevant line ma nager and the o fficer will be kept fully
informed of the progress being made.Produced by Staffordshire Police
for FOI 23088HRD 8
Oct 13 V4.0
NOT PROTECTIVELY MARKEDThe following timescales will apply (all days are working days)
• Written notice to attend a Stage 1 or 2 Meeting – as soon as reasonably practicable.
• An alternate date required from the original date – within 5 days of the original date.
• Provide a written record (decisions/actions) following a Stage 1 or 2 Meeting – as
soon as reasonably possible after the date of meeting.
• Improvement Action Plan, if applicable, following Stage 1 or 2 Me eting – as soon as
reasonably practicable after the date of meeting (within 10 days).
• Written Improvement Notice, if applicable, following Stage 1, 2 or 3 Meeting – as
soon as reasonably practicable (within 10 days) after the date of meeting.
• Officers’ entitlement to submit written co mments on any written record of a meeting
to the line manager (where no appeal has been lodged) – within 7 days following
receipt of the written record of the meeting.
• ‘Specified period’ of an improvement notice – should normally not exceed 3 months
(may be extended but must not exceed 12 months).
• ‘Validity period’ of an improvement notice – 12 months from the date of the notice
within which performance/attendance must be maintained.
• Officer’s request for an appeal following the receipt of the written
record/improvement notice/action plan following a Stage 1 or 2 Meeting - within 7 days
following receipt.
• Appeal Meetings at Stage 1 or 2 – should normally take place within 7 days of the
Appeal being received by the second/third line manager (may be extended by a further
5 days howev er, the o fficer must be informed in writing and the reason for the
extension).
• Written notice of decision following an appeal meeting at Stage 1 or 2 - within 3
days.
• Written notice to attend a Stage 3 Meeting – as soon as is reasonably practicable.
• Third stage meeting will t ake place no later han 30 days from the date of the
notification to of ficer advising them they will be required to attend a Stage 3 Meeting.
(This may be extended beyond 30 days at t he direction of a Panel Chair). All parties
must be informed of the decision. An alternate date must be within 5 day s of the
original date.
• Exchange of details of witnesses - no later than 10 days before the meeting
• Officer’s response to a Stage 3 notification, e.g. acceptance of unsatisfactory
performance/attendance, mitigation, which elements are to be disputed etc – within
14 days of he date on whi ch the notice was issued.
• Officer’s objection to the panel members prior to a Stage 3 Meeting – within 3 days
following receipt of panel detail notification.
• Provide a written record (decisions/actions) following a Stage 3 Meeting – within 3
days of the meeting.10.0 Formal Procedure
Having considered the use of informal management action ( see Section 8 ), where a line
manager considers that the officer’s performance or attendance is unsatisfactory and it is
clear that improvement would not be achievable with a short extension to the current
plan(s) in place, the matter will be dealt with in accordance with Stage 1 of the formal
procedures. The first line manager, in consultation wi th the relevant HR Officer / HR
Manager, will arrange a formal meeting with the o fficer to discuss his/her
performance/attendance. In line with the sickness absence procedure, t his may also
include instances whereby an Individual Support Plan is not met. (See Section 9.1 fo r
Overview of Formal Procedures)
Produced by Staffordshire Police
for FOI 23088HRD 8
Oct 13 V4.0
NOT PROTECTIVELY MARKED10.1 Notification to attend Stage 1 meeting
The Stage 1 meeting will be held by the first line m anager. The relevant Human
Resources Officer/Human Resources Manager will attend as an advi sor. The first line
manager will write to the individual providing at least 10 working days notice of the
meeting (UPAP 1 -Letter Template 1). Should an officer or their representative be unable
to attend the meeting at the time and date specified by the line manager, the Police
Officer may propose alternative arrangements. Providing that the alternative t me is
reasonable and falls within 5 working days (beginning with the first working day) after tha t
specified by the line manager, the meeting must be postponed to that time.The letter will confirm the following:
• Date and Time of the meeting
• A summary of the reasons why the line manager considered the performance or
attendance unsatisfactory
• The possible outcomes of a first stage, second stage and third stage meeting
• That a HR representative will attend as an advisor
• That prior to the meeting the o fficer must provide the line manager with any
documentation he or she intends to rely on in the meeting
• T hat he/she may be accompanied at the meeting by a Police friend.The first line manager will also sen d the o fficer a copy of this procedure and any other
documentation that will be referred to at the meetingShould the officer concerned raise a grievance or otherwise object to the manager holding
a first stage meeting then the meeting will still be held by the manager. If the o fficer
considers that they have sufficient grounds for appeal, the object ion of the o fficer should
be handled in accordance with the appeals process at Section 17.0.Where the officer concerned does not attend a meeting or where the officer participates in
a third stage meeting by video link or other means, s/he may be represented at the
meeting by a Police friend, and in third stage meetings (where the process was initiate d
due to alleged Gross Incompetence) ; by a relevant lawyer. The meeting may proceed in
the officers’ absence and a decision made, whether the officer has representation or not.The officer should al so provide the line manager with any docu ments to which h e/she
intends to refer at the meeting. Any docu ment(s) that are not submitted prior to the
meeting may be considered at t he discretion of the line manager e.g. if the document was
not available to be subm itted in advance. Where a document is permitted to b e
considered, a short adjournment may be necessary to enable parties present to consider
its implications.10.2 Stage One Meeting
The purpose of the meeting is to hear the evidence of the unsatisfactory performance or
attendance and to give the officer the opportunity to respond. It is also an opportunity to
hear of any factors that are affecting the o fficer’s performance or attendance and what
Produced by Staffordshire Police
for FOI 23088HRD 8
Oct 13 V4.0
NOT PROTECTIVELY MARKEDthe individual considers can be done to address them.
At the meeting the line manager (accompanied by a Hu man R esources Officer/Human
Resources Manager) will:• explain to the officer the reasons why the performance or attendance of the
Police Officer is unsatisfactory;
• provide the o fficer with the opportunity to make representations in
response, listen, ask questions and comment as appropriate
• provide his or her Police friend with an opportunity to make representations
• provide the officer (and/or his or her Police friend) with an opportunity to respond,
ask questions and comment as appropriate.A sufficient writte n record of the dis cussions must be made. The meeting may be
adjourned at any time if the line manager considers it appropriate to do so.In circumstances where, having considered representation, the line manager
considers the performance or attendance unsatisfactory, he/she must:• inform the o fficer in what respect (s) his or her performance or attendance is
considered unsatisfactory;
• inform the o fficer of the im provement that is required in his or her performance or
attendance;
• inform the o fficer that, if a sufficient improvement is not made within the specified
period (should not usually exceed 3 m onths) set by the line manager, he or she may
be required to attend a second stage meeting;
• inform the officer that he or she wi ll receive a Written Improvement Notice and
a Performance Action Plan.
• inform the officer that if a sufficient improvement in his or her performance or
attendance is not maintained during the v alidity period (12 months from date of notice)
of such notice he or she may be required to attend a second stage meeting.
• consider the appropriateness of the continuation of any Competency Related
Threshol
d Payments (CRTP) and advise the o fficer of the decision as to whether this
will continueCompetency Related Threshold Payments
It is acknowledged that Competency Related Threshold Payments (CRTP) are currently
being phased out incrementally as part of the Winsor Review of Police Officer Pay and
Conditions. However, until the cessation of CRTP on 01 April 2016, the finding or
admission of uns atisfactory performance or attendance (including gross incompetence)
will not automatically result in the removal of any amount of competency related threshold
payment that an officer is in receipt of. Howe ver, where an individual has receiv ed a
Written Improvement Notice or Final Written Improvement Notice, this may trigger a
review of the appropriateness of that Police Officer continuing to receive such payments.
Any review should take into account the qualifying criteria for payments under these
schemes.10.3 Procedure following the First Stage meeting
Produced by Staffordshire Police
for FOI 23088HRD 8
Oct 13 V4.0
NOT PROTECTIVELY MARKEDAs soon as reasonably practicable, the F irst Line Manager will contact the officer to
confirm the decision taken as a result of the first stage meeting. T his should be done in
writing within 10 days (or as soon as reasonably practical) of the meeting and provide the
officer with the following documentation:• A written record (summary) of the meeting
• Details of a Performance Action Plan (Lotus Notes Database)
• A signed and dated Written Improvement Notice
• Procedure and Contact for submitting an appealA copy of the Written Improvement Notice should also be provided to any other relevant
parties. (UPAP 10 – Template for Written Improvement Notice).The officer should also be informed that of their right to s ubmit written comments on the
written record of the meeting (within 7 days) provided the officer has not exercised his/her
right to appeal.10.4 Written Improvement Notice (W.I.N)
A Written Improvement Notice is a formal document which contains the details of what
needs to improve in terms of an o fficer’s performance or attendance and is supported by
a Performance Action Plan.An Improvement Notice must state:
• In what respect the officer’s performance or attendance is considered
unsatisfactory
• The improvement in performance or attendance required to enable the Police
Officer to reach an acceptable standard;
• A ‘specified period’ within which improvement is expected to be made
• A ‘validity period of the Written Improvement Notice (12 months)
• The possible consequences if improvement is not made or maintained within
the ‘specified period’ or within the 12 month validity periodA copy of the W.I.N should be retained on the o fficer’s personal file for the length of the
validity period and will also be recorded on the Performance Assessment Unit computer
system .10.5 Performance Action Plan
Line Managers should ensure that a Performance Action Plan is completed on the Action
Plan Database within Lotus Notes . The Performance Action Plan is used to set out the
actions which should assist the Police Officer to perform their duties to an acceptable
standard. If possible, the P erformance Action Plan should be agreed either at the first
stage meeting or at a later time specified by the line manager that is no later than 10 days
following the Stage 1 meeting.It is expected that the o fficer will co-operate with the implementation of the Performance
Action Plan and take responsibility for their own development or improvement. Equally,
Prod ced by Staffordshire Police
for FOI 23088HRD 8
Oct 13 V4.0
NOT PROTECTIVELY MARKEDthe line manager must ensure that any actions to support the officer to improve are
implemented.For cases concerning unsatisfactory attendance the Performance Action Plan should
outline the actions and support to assist the officer in improving their attendance at work.For further information, please refer to the Sickness Absence Policy.
A Performance Action Plan should include:
• identify any weaknesses which may be the cause of unsatisfactory performance or
attendance;
• outline what steps the o fficer must take to improve performance and/or attendance
• Identify and include any support that is available from the organisation e.g. training and
support;
• specify stated review period(s) within which actions identified should be followed up;
and set date(s) for an assessment/review of the Police Officer’s performance or
attendance
• Confirm the date of the Improvement Review meeting (end of specified period)10.6 The Specified Period of a Written Improvement Notice and Performance Action
PlanThe ‘specified period’ of an Improvement N otice and P erformance Action Plan is a period
specified by the line manager within which the officer must improve his or her performance
or attendance. It is expec ted that the specified period for improvement would not normally
exceed 3 months.However, depending on the nature and circumstances, it may be appropriate to specify a
longer or shorter period for improvement In all cases an improvement notice should not
exceed 12 months.10.7 The Validity Period of a Written Improvement Notice and Performance Action Plan
The ‘validity period’ of an Improvement Notice is the period of 12 months from the date of
the notice within which performance or attendance must be maintained (assuming
improvement is made during the specified period). If the improvement is not maintained
within this period then the next stage of the procedures may be used.10.8 mprovement Extensions (Unforeseen Circumstances)
It may be appropriate to extend a Written Impr ovement Notice, for example, where an
officer has been absent from the workplace as a result of certified sickness absence in
the context of the performance issue and is unable to demonstrate whether or not the
required improvement has been achieved.Such requests for an extension to a Written Improvement Notice should be referred to the
appropriate authority, who in consultation with a Human Resources Representative will
review the circumstances leading to the request in order to consider extending the
specified period, if is appropriate to do so.
Produced by Staffordshire Police
for FOI 23088HRD 8
Oct 13 V4.0
NOT PROTECTIVELY MARKEDIn any such case, unless the appropriate authority (or nominated deputy) is satisfied that
there are exceptional circumstances making it appropriate, any such period may not be
extended if it would result in the total length of the specified period exceeding 12 months.11.0 Assessment of Performance/Attendance – Improvement Review Meeting
During both the ‘specified’ and ‘validity’ periods, the Officer’s performance/attendance
must be regularly and acti vely moni tored against the Improvement Notice and
Performance Action Plan. During this period, line managers should discuss any concerns
that they have as regards the Officer ’s performance or attendance and offer advice and
guidance where appropriate.As soon as reasonably practicable after the specified period of the Improvement N otice
and Performance Action Plan, the line manager, in consultation with a HR Officer /HR
Manager must formally assess the performance or attendance of the Police Officer during
that period.If there has been a satisfactory improvem ent in the Officer ’s performance and/or
attendance, the line manager should acknowledge and encourage the Officer to sustain
the improvement. This should be undertaken in writing (See template letter UPAP3). The
notification should also inform the Officer that whilst the performance or attendance is now
satisfactory, the Improvement Notice is valid for 12 months from the date on the notice,
advising that it is possible for the second stage of the procedure (Stage 2) to be initiated if
the performance or attendance of the officer falls below an acceptable level within the
validity period.If the line manager considers that the Police Officer’s performance or attendance is still
unsatisfactory, the line manager should notify the Police Officer in writing of this. The line
manager must also notify the Officer that there is now a requirement for him/her to attend a
second stage meeting to consider the ongoing performance or attendance issues. (See
template letter UPAP 4)The same process should be undertaken in circumstan ces where the Officer ’s
performance and/or attendance has fallen below an acceptable lev el during the
remainder of the validity period.Where an Officer is required to attend a second stage meeting and at that meeting it is
found that the performance or attendance of the Officer has improved, he or she can still
be required to attend another Stage 2 meeting if they do not maintain their performance
within the 12 months that the improvement notice (W.I.N) is valid.11 1 Stage One Appeals
A Police Officer has a right of appeal against the finding and the terms of the I mprovement
Notice / Performance Action Plan imposed at stage one of the procedure. Further
information regarding the appeal process can be found at Section 17.0.12.0 Stage 2 Meeting
If following an assessment of performance or attendance at the end of t he
Produced by Staffordshire Police
for FOI 23088HRD 8
Oct 13 V4.0
NOT PROTECTIVELY MARKEDspecified period set at Stage 1 or during the validity period of the notice t he Officer’s
performance/attendance remains/ becomes unsa tisfactory, the second line manager, in
consultation with the relevant HR M anager/Officer will notify the Police Officer in writing
of the requirement for them to attend a second stage meeting.The process illustrated in Section 10 should be followed. During Stage 2, the second
line manager will co- ordinate and chair appropriate activity. It should be noted that a
Stage 2 Meeting if required, must be similar to or connected with the unsatisfactory
performance or attendance referred to in the Written Improvement Notice issued at
Stage 1.The purpose of a Stage 2 meeting is to hear the evidence of the unsatisfactory
performance or attendance and to give the Police Officer the opportunity to put forward
their views. It is also an opportunity to hear of any factors that are continuing to affect
the Police Officer’s performance or attendance and what the Police Officer considers
can be done to address them.The maximum outcome at stage two of the procedure is a Final Written Improvement
Notice (F.W.I.N). The Officer concerned should be made aware of the possible
outcomes, should the procedure be followed to the final stage (Stage 3) namely:• Dismissal
• A reduction in rank (Performance cases only)
• Redeployment to alternative duties
• Extension to the Final Written Improvement Notice (one occasion)12.1 Procedure following Stage 2 meeting
As soon as reasonably practicab e following the Stage 2 meeting, the second line
manager will contact the Officer to confirm the decision taken as a result of the evidence
presented at the meeting. This should be done in writing within 10 days (or as soon as
reasonably practical) of the meeting and provide t he Officer with the following
documentation:• A written record (summary) of the meeting
• Details of a Performance Action Plan (Lotus Notes Database)
• A signed and dated Final Written Improvement Notice
• Procedure and Contact for submitting an appeal12.2 A ssessment of Performance or Attendance - Improvement Review
At the end of the specified period for stage 2, an Improvement Review will take place
with the second line manager and HR Officer /HR Manager in order to review the Final
Written Improvement Noti ce and to assess the performance and attendance of the
individual.Where it is considered that the Police Officer’s performance or attendance remains
unsatisfactory the second line manager and HR Representative should liaise with the
Performance Assessment Unit Manager to discuss the ongoing issues and to initiate
Stage 3 of the procedure where applicable.Produced by Staffordshire Police
for FOI 23088HRD 8
Oct 13 V4.0
NOT PROTECTIVELY MARKEDIn such circumstances where it has been agreed that progression to Stage 3 is
required, the Police Officer should receive written notification of the r equirement to
attend a Stage 3 meeting.12.3 Stage 2 Appeals
Any appeal at Stage 2 should be held in accordance with the process at Section 17.0.
13.0 Gross Incompetence (direct to Stage 3 for performance issues only)
In cases of ‘gross incompetence’, Unsatisfactory Performance is defined in Regulation 4
of the Police (Performance) Regulations 2012 as:‘ a serious inability or failure of a Police Officer to perform the duties of the role or rank
he/she is currently undertaking to a satisfactory standard or level, to the extent that
dismissal would be justified, except that no account shall be taken of the attendance of a
Police Officer when considering whether he has been grossly incompetent.’This would usually be as a result of a single inci dent of ‘gross incom petence’. A series of
acts over a period of time would not initiate the procedures at the third stage.All cases of potential Gross Incompetence must be referred to the Performance
Assessment Unit for assessment and decision.Having reviewed the relevant documentation and in full consultation with an Executive
Officer, it may be necessary for the Performance Assessment Unit to forward the case
directly to a Stage 3 Meeting.The Performance Assessment Unit will establish the facts of the incompetence including
possible witness statements and the Officer’s response to the incident(s).If a decision to proceed to Stage 3 is made, the Senior Manager must notify the Officer in
writing as soon as is reasonably practicable that he or she is required to attend a Stage
3 Meeting.13.1 Stage 3 Meeting for Gross Incompetence
The meeting will take place no sooner than 21 days, (but no later than 30 days) following
the date of written not ification to att end a Stage 3 m eeting. The notice will confirm the
arrangements for the meeting, including the reason for the meeting, details of the areas
of concern and a summary of how this is considered to con stitute gross incompetence,
and possible outcomes of the meeting. The notice must also advise the indi vidual of the
effect of Regulation 6, in that he/she has the right to be legally represented by a relevant
lawyer of his/her choice and if an Officer chooses not to be legally represented they may
be accompanied at the meeting by a Police friend. Notification must also stipulate that the
range of outcomes can be imposed regardless, if legal representation is refused.The notice must include copies of related documentation to be relied upon by the line
manager. The names of the panel members should be provided to the Officer as soon as
they have been appointed.
Produced by Staffordshire Police
for FOI 23088HRD 8
Oct 13 V4.0
NOT PROTECTIVELY MARKED14.0 Stage 3 – Meeting (following Stages 1 and 2)
Following the decision to proceed to Stage 3, the Second Line Manager and HR
Officer/HR Manager will pr ovide a written confirmation letter to the Officer informing
him/her that they are required to attend a third stage meeting to consider the
performance/attendance issues in more detail.If the second line manager considers that the Officer concerned has failed to maintain a
sufficient improvement in his /her performance or attendance during any part of the
validity period of the final written improvement notice remaining after the expiry of the
specified period, the Officer must be notified in writing of the following:1) The reasons why the performance or attendance is considered to be an
insufficient improvement.2) That the Officer is required to attend a third stage m eeting to consider his
performance and/or attendance.Any third stage meeting which a Police Officer is required to attend must concern
unsatisfactory performance or attendance which is similar or connected with the
unsatisfactory performance or attendance re ferred to in the Final W ritten Improvement
Notice.The Stage 3 meeting will take place no sooner than 21 working days, (but no later than
30 working days) following the date of written notification to at tend a Stage 3 meeting.
The notice will confirm the arrangements for the meeting referring to the requirement on
the Officer to attend with a panel appointed by the Performance Assessment Unit.The written confirmation will also include the reason for the meeting, details of the areas
of con cern, possible outcomes of the meeting and t o adv ise the indi vidual that he/she
may be accompanied at the meeting by a Police friend.The notice must also include copies of r elated documentation relied upon by the
Second Line Manager, HR Representative and Performance Assessment Unit (PAU)
when the decision was made to progress to Stage 3 of the procedure. The names of the
panel members should be provided to the Officer as soon as they have been appointed.Within working 14 da ys of the date of the notice, the Officer must provide in
writing:• whether they accept that their performance or attendance has
been unsatisfactory or has been grossly incompetent (as
applicable);
• in cases of acceptance, any relevant mitigation;
• in cases of non acceptance, or where the Officer disputes some or
all of the content of the notice, then the Officer must state the matters for
dispute, provide his/her account and/or any argument on points of law
he/she wishes to be considered by the panel.Produced by Staffordshire Police
for FOI 23088HRD 8
Oct 13 V4.0
NOT PROTECTIVELY MARKED14.1 Panel Membership and Procedure
Panel Membership, appoint ed by the appropriate authority (see Secti on 7.0) will be as
follows:1st panel member (Chair): A Senior Officer (ACC or above)
2nd panel member: Police Officer of at least the rank of Superintendent;
or Head of People Services or their nominated deputy
(HR)3rd panel member: Police Officer of at least the rank of S uperintendent;
or Police staff who is at least equivalent to that rank.At least one of the three panel members must be a Police Officer and one should be
a Senior Human Resources pr ofessional. Panel members must be of at least the
same rank or equivalent to the Officer concerned and may be from another Police
service. No panel member will be an interested party.The role of the Senior Human Resources Professional and Senior Police Officer is to
advise the panel e.g. procedures, application etc. A Solicitor may also advise the panel
on points of law.As soon as panel members have been appointed arrangements should be made
for copies of all relevant documentation to be f orwarded to them. In particular, any
document:• that was available to the line manager in relation to any first stage meeting;
• which was available to the second line m anager in relation to any
second stage meeting;
• which was prepared or submitted in advance of those meetings;
• which was prepared or submitted following those meetings i.e.
improvement noti ces, performance action plans and meeting notes;
• relating to any appeal14.2 Objection to panel members
The O ficer has the right to ob ject to any panel members appoi nted and any
such objection must be made in writing (within 3 days following panel notification) to the
Head of People Services or his/her nominated deputy (or nominated person). The Officer
must include the grounds of his or her objection to a panel member (s) in that submission.The Officer must be informed in writing whether his/her appeal is upheld or rejected.
If the appeal is upheld, a new panel member will be appointed as a replacement. As soon
as practicable after any such a ppointment, the Officer will be informed in writing of the
name of the new panel member . If the Officer objects to the new panel member the
process must be repeated.Produced by Staffordshire Police
for FOI 23088HRD 8
Oct 13 V4.0
NOT PROTECTIVELY MARKED14.3 Special Constables and Stage 3 Meetings
In cases where the Officer is a Special C onstable, as indicated above, the constabul ary
will appoint a member of the special constabulary to attend t he meeting to advise the
panel. This is for the purpose of fairness so that any significant differences between the
role of a regular and Special Police Constable which may have a bearing on the Officer’s
performance or attendance can be taken into account.The special constable advising the panel must have sufficient seniority and experience of
the special constabulary to be able to advise the panel. The S pecial C onstable
advising the panel can be an Officer of another Police Service.The Special Constable advisor will not form part of the panel and will not have a role in
determining whether or not the Officer’s performance or attendance is unsatisfactory.In arranging a third stage meeting invol ving special constables, consideration should b e
given to the fact that special constables are unpaid volunt eers and may therefore have
full time employment or other personal commitments.14.4 Witnesses and evidence
The attendance of witnesses at Stage 3 should be ag reed by the Officer and the senior
manager, in consultation with the Head of People Services (or nominated person i.e.
Performance Assessment Unit Manager) prior to the meeting. The Panel Chair will
make the f inal decision as to the list of witnesses for both the management and Officer
side. All witnesses should be provided with details of arrangements for the meeting.14.5 Documentation
All documents to be referred/relied upon at Stage 3 should be submitted and exc hanged
between parties prior to the meeting. Any document(s) that are not submitted prior to the
meeting may be considered at the discretion of the line manager e.g. if the document
was not available to be submitted in advance. Where a document is permitted to be
considered, a short adjournment may be necessary to enable parties present to consider
its implications14.6 Purpose of the Stage 3 Meeting
The purpose of the meeting is for the panel to hear the evidence of the unsatisfactory
performance and/or attendance and to provide an opportunity for the Officer to put
forward their case.At Stage 3, the panel chair will:
• explain to the Officer the reasons why the performance and/or
attendance is considered unsatisfactory;
• provide the Officer with the opportunity to make representations in response;
• where the case is one of gross incompetence and the Officer has opted
f or legal representation, provide the Officer’s legal representative with the
opportunity to make representations;
• provide the Officer’s ‘Police friend’ with an opportunity to make
Produced by Staffordshire Police
for FOI 23088HRD 8
Oct 13 V4.0
NOT PROTECTIVELY MARKEDrepre sentations
The meeting may be adjourned at any time if the Panel Chair considers it appropriate
to do so.A record of the meeting will be made by a sound recording. The Officer will be
provided with a copy on request.14.7 Possible Outcomes of a Stage 3 Meeting
(Following Stage 1 and 2 – NOT Gross Incompetence)
• Redeployment to alternative duties (may involve a reduction in rank);
• Reduction in rank (in the case of performance only)
• Dismissal (with a minimum of 28 days notice) or
• Extension of a Final Written Improvement Notice 1
• No Action RequiredPossible Outcomes of a Stage 3 Meeting
(Direct to a Stage 3 – Gross Incompetence)
• Redeployment to alternative duties (may involve a reduction in rank);
• Issue of a Final Written Improvement Notice 2
• Reduction in rank (with immediate effect);
• Dismissal (with immediate effect) or
• Issue of a Written Improvement Notice 3 (if the panel considers that there has
been unsatisfactory performance and not gross incompetence).The Panel must confirm the decision and their reasons as well as any outcome which
they order, to both the Officer and the second line manager (within 3 days). The above
notification must be accompanied by details of their right to appeal, the appeals
procedure (Section 17.0) and the name of the individual whom the appeal should be
sent.1 Extension of a final written improvement notice
Where the panel is sues an extension to the Final Written Improvement Notice (Stage
3 Meeting, following Stage 1 and 2 – NOT gross incompetence), a new period must be
‘specified’ within which improvement to performance or attendance must occur. The
12 month validity period of the F inal Written Improvement Notice will apply in full from
the date of the notice. If follow ing a Panel Assessment performance/attendance
remains unsatisfactory at the end of t he ‘specified period’ or during the remainder of
the validity period becomes unsatisfactory, a further S tage 3 Meeting will be invoked.
Only one extension to a Final Written Improvement Notice can be issued.2 Issue of a final written improvement notice
In circumstances wher e the Stage 3 Panel issues a final written improvement notice
(Stage 3 Meeting - gross incompetence), a period must be ‘speci fied’ within which
Produced by Staffordshire Police
for FOI 23088HRD 8
Oct 13 V4.0
NOT PROTECTIVELY MARKEDimprovement to performance or attendance must occur. The 12 month validity period
of the final written improvement notice will apply from the date of the notice. If following
a Panel Assessment performance/attendance r emains unsatisfactory at the end of
each ‘specified period’ or becomes unsatisfactory during the remai nder of t he validity
period, a further Stage 3 Meeting will be invoked.3 Issue of a written improvement notice
In circumstances where the pane l issues a W ritten Improvement Notice (Stage 3 Meeting
- gross incompetence), a period must be ‘specified’ within which improvement to
performance or attendance must occur. A 12 month validity period of the I mprovement
Notice will also apply from the date of the notice. If following a Panel Assessmen t
performance/attendance remains unsatisfactory at the end of each ‘specifi ed period’ or
becomes unsatisfactory during the remainder of the validity period, a Stage 2 Meeting will
be invoked. Please note a Stage 2 Meeting if required, must be simi ar to or connected
with the unsatisfactory performance or attendance referred to in the Written Improvement
Notice.If a further Stage 3 Meeting is convened, the panel should be composed of the same
panel members unless it is not possible to do so, in which case the Officer must be
informed in writing of any new pan el members. The Offic er will have the opportunity to
object to any new panel member.An Officer may only be given an extension to a Final Improvement Notice on one
occasion. Therefore, where the Officer is required to attend a reconvened Stage 3
Meeting and the panel deter mines that the performance/attendance remains
unsatisfactory, the only outcomes available to the panel are:• Redeployment to alternative duties (may involve a reduction in rank);
• Reduction in rank (in cases of performance only); or
• Dismissal (with a minimum of 28 days notice).In cases where an Officer was issued with a Written Improvement Notice (as opposed to
a F inal Written Improvement Notice) for unsatisfactor y performance at a ‘gross
incompetence’ Stage 3 Meeting, the Written Improvement Notice will be equivalent to a
Written Improvement N otice at a Stage 1 M eeting. The procedure for assessing the
performance will be the same following a Stage 1 Meeting i.e. if no/sustained
improvement, progress to Stage 2 meeting.14.8 Appeals
Any appeal should be held in accordance with Section 17.0.
14 9 Inability to attend a Stage 3 Meeting
If the Officer informs the panel chair in advance that he/she is unable to attend
the meeting on grounds which the panel chair considers ‘reasonable’, the panel chair may
allow the Officer to participate in the meeting by video link or other means.In cases where the Officer is absent (for example through illness or injury) a short delay
may be reasonable to allow him or her to attend. If this is not possible or any delay is
Produced by Staffordshire Police
for FOI 23088HRD 8
Oct 13 V4.0
NOT PROTECTIVELY MARKEDconsidered not appropriate in the circumstances then the panel chair may allow the Officer
to participate by telephone or vi deo link. A Police friend will be able to attend the meeting
to represent the O fficer in the normal way (and, in the case of a gross incompetence
meeting, the Officer’s legal representative, where appointed).In cases where the Officer does not attend the meeting and provides no notification, albeit
the panel chair is satisfied that good reason for such non- attendance is given by (or on
behalf of) the Officer, he or she may postpone, or as the case may be, adjourn the
meeting.The attendance, in person or otherwise, of the Officer is not necessary for Stage 3
Meeting proceedings to be valid. Where a meeting is postponed or adjourned because of
absence, the panel chair may nonetheless decide to hold the meeting or resume the
meeting.15.0 Stage 3 Meeting Administration
Any action within the stages of thi s procedure including the outcome of any meetings will
be recorded on the Performance Assessment Unit computer system .This will include:
• Correspondence relating to all meetings
• A copy of the Performance Action Plan(s)
• Written Improvement Notices
• The line manager's and individual's response (s)
• Written record of meeting(s)
• Written comments by the Officer on the written ecord
• Appeal documentation
• Personal information to allow compliance with organisational and legislative
requirementsRecords will be treated as confidential and kept in accordance with Data Protection
requirements. Records may be subject to disclosure in the event of any related misconduct
action or Employment Tribunal16.0 Roles and Responsibilities
The Panel Chair will ensure that:
Stage 3 Meetings are held in accordance with this procedure;
• Assessments of Performance/Attendance are conducted in accordance with
this procedure (Following an extension/ issue of a Final/Written I mprovement
Notice)The Head of People Services (or nominated deputy) will ensure that:
Advice is provided to panel members during Stage 3 Meetings;
The procedure is kept under review and revised to comply with changes in Police
Produced by Staffordshire Police
for FOI 23088HRD 8
Oct 13 V4.0
NOT PROTECTIVELY MARKEDRegulations and/or at the direction of the Force Executive.
A Senior Human Resources Professional will ensure:
• Consultation with the Performance Assessment Unit is taken in cases
where a D ecision is required as to whether the matter is misconduct or
unsatisfactory performance and progression to Stage 3 meeting;
• Support is provided during Stage 2 Appeal Meetings;
• Advice is provided as to whether a Stage 3 Meeting is convened;
• Advice is provided as to whether a Stage 3 Meeting (Gross Incompetence)
is convened;
• Confirm in writing, as to whether Officer’s objection to a St age 3 Panel Member
is upheld;
• Witnesses and their attendance are agreed prior to a Stage 3 Meeting;
• Advice is provided to panel members during a Stage 3 Meeting;
• Advice is provided in cases where a referral is made to a Selected
Medical Practitioner under Police Pension Regulations.The Joint Legal Services Representative (or nominated deputy) will ensure that:
• Advice is provided to panel members during Stage 3 Meetings
• Advice is provided on procedure and/or due to changes in Po ice RegulationsHuman Resources Officers/Managers are responsible for ensuring that:
• Line Managers receive advice and support in t he operation of the Police
Performance and Attendance Procedures;
• The procedure is applied fairly and consistently;
• They are present during Meetings and Appeal Meetings as an advisor;
• All cases are recorded and monitored in accordance with the force
Equality and Diversity requirements and other organisational and legislative
requirement s;
• All documentation is recorded accurately and appropriately;
• Consideration is given to commencing formal procedures, together with the
line manager in cases where i nformal management action has been taken but
was declined by the Officer, or
• F ailed to bring about the necessary improvement in his/her
attendance/performance and/or when the Officer is long term sick and despite
supportive action having been taken, there is no realistic prospect of a return
to work in a reasonable timeframe.
• Advice is sought from Occupational Health and/or Force Medical Advisor
where appropriate.
• Assessments of Performance/Attendance are conducted in accordance with
this procedure.Line Managers and Senior Managers are responsible for ensuring that:
• Individual o fficers are aware of t he standards of performance/attendance
expected of them and the obligations placed upon them by the force and
appropriate action is taken when these standards are not maintained;
Produced by Staffordshire Police
for FOI 23088HRD 8
Oct 13 V4.0
NOT PROTECTIVELY MARKED• Advice is sought from the relevant HR manager/Officer when considering
action under this procedure;
• Any decision(s) following a formal meeting are confirmed in writ ing, incl uding
any Improvement Plans;
• Assessments of Performance/Attendance are conducted in accordance with
this procedure;
• Appeals are conducted in accordance with this procedure;
• All documentation is recorded accurately and appropriately;Individual Officers are responsible for ensuring that:
• They take personal responsibility for their continuous personal development
• every effort is made to return to work at the first opportunity;
• they provide information to enable balanced and appropriate decisions to be made;
• every effort is made to attend a meeting;
• responsibilities under the Sickness Absence/ Unsatisfactory Performance
Procedures are adhered to;
• no action is undertaken which may delay the process of recovery and/or
this procedure and related procedure;
• consideration is given to seek advice or represen ation from either a Police
‘friend’ or association;
• information is provided to comply with the force’s Equality schemes and
other organisational and legislative requirementsOfficer Representatives/Police Friend are responsible for ensuring that:
• Adequate representation is provided at meetings where requested by the
Officer, namely to:- advise the Officer concerned throughout the process
- respond on the Officer s behalf to any views expressed at a meeting
- present and sum up the individual’s case
- make representations concerning any aspect of the procedures
- (in the case of a Stage 3 Meeting) ask questions of any witnessesThe Officer Representative/Police Friend (including a relevant lawyer in third
stage meetings for gross incompetence) may not answer any questions asked of
the Officer during a meeting.Occupational Health, Safety & Welfare Unit are responsible for providing advice on:
• the nature and extent of an Officer’s medical/health problems;
• when the medical/health problem is likely to be resolved;
• whether an Officer will be fit to carry out his/her duties on his or her
return to work;
• the duties that the Officer may be fit to undertake;
• the Officer’s medical/health condition and duties under Equality
legislation;
• whether there are any adjustments or adaptations to the work,
Produced by Staffordshire Police
for FOI 23088HRD 8
Oct 13 V4.0
NOT PROTECTIVELY MARKEDequipment or workplace that might assist in improving attendance /
performance;
• the likelihood of the medical/health condition recurring or of some
other medical/health condition emerging;
• any concerns raised by the Officer about their medical/health
condition and/or working environment;
• whether the Police Officer may be permanently disabled as defined
under the Police pension Regulations
• welfare support available to the Officer(Please note: this list is not exhaustive)
17.0 The Appeals Procedure
A Police Officer has a right of appeal against the finding and the terms of the
Improvement Notice imposed at stage one and two of the unsatisfactory
performance and attendance procedure. However, any finding and outcome of the
first or second stage meeting will continue to apply up to the date that the appeal is
determined. Therefore where and Officer contests the finding our outcome at either
Stage 1 or Stage 2, they should continue to follow the terms of the Improvement
Notice and any accompanying P erformance Action Plan, pending the determination
of the appeal.17.1 Appeal Stage 1 and 2
An Officer has the right of appeal against the outcome(s) during any stage of the
formal procedures. For Stages 1 and 2 this should be within 7 days of the receipt
of the I mprovement Notice and written record of t he meeting (unless the
timescale is extended by the relevant manager following an appli cation by the
Officer). The notice of appeal must clearly set out the grounds and be
accompanied by evidence for the appeal.The grounds for appeal are:
• that the finding of unsatisfactory performance or attendance is unreasonable;
• that any of the terms of the Improvement Notice are unreasonable;
• that there is new evidence that could not reasonably have been considered at the
first/second stage meeting which could have materially affected the finding of
unsatisfactory performance or attendance or any of the terms of the improvement
notice;
• that there was a serious breach of the procedures set out in the Police
(Performance) Regulations 2012 or other unfairness which could have materially
affected the finding of unsatisfactory performance or attendance or the terms of
the improvement notice.17.2 Stage 2 Appeal only
In addition to the above the additional grounds for appeal are:
Produced by Staffordshire Police
for FOI 23088HRD 8
Oct 13 V4.0
NOT PROTECTIVELY MARKED• that the Police Officer should not have been required to attend the second
stage meeting as the meeting did not concern unsatisfactory performance or
attendance which was similar to or connected with the unsatisfactory
performance or attendance referred to in the Written Improvement Notice that
followed the first stage meeting.Appeal Meetings will normally be held within 7 days of the Appeal being received
by the next line manager where practicable:Stage 1 Second Line Manager
Stage 2 Senior Manager – (Third Line Manager)
Stage 3 Police Appeals TribunalWhere a Second or Third Line Manager has been involved in previous stages of
the process, in order to avoid a conflict of interest at appeal stage, a nominated
person must be appointed.The Officer has the right to be accompanied and represented by a Police friend.
(See Section 16 – Roles and Responsibilities).17.3 Stage 1 and 2 Appeal Meetings
Following notification of appeal, the relevant manager should write to the Officer to
confirm the following;• the date and time of the meeting;
• a HR Manager/Officer or a Police Officer may attend the meeting to advise
the second line manager on the proceedings;
• any other person specified in the notice may attend the meeting;
• the right to seek advice from a representative of his/her staff association; and
• the right to be accompanied and represented by a Police friend.At the Appeal Meeting, the relevant manager, having considered representations
may:• confirm or reverse the findings of unsatisfactory performance or attendance;
• endorse or vary the terms of the Written Improvement Notice (in such
circumstances, any change will be retrospective and apply from the date
of the Improvement Notice).Within 3 days of the conclusion of the appeal meeting, the Officer will be given
written notice of the relevant manager’s decision. If the chair is in a position to
send a written summary of the reasons for that decision, then this may also
accompany the written notice of the decision.In circumstances where the relevant chair sends only the written notice of the
decision to the Officer, the chair will send a written summary of reasons for that
decision within 5 days.17.4 Stage 3 Appeals – Police Appeals Tribunal
Produced by Staffordshire Police
for FOI 23088HRD 8
Oct 13 V4.0
NOT PROTECTIVELY MARKEDAn Officer has the right of appeal against the outcome of a Stage 3 Meeting. Appeals
must be made within 10 working days of the dat e when the written decision of the
stage 3 meeting is received. The appeal will be made to the Police Appeals Tribunal,
clearly setting out the grounds for appeal and must be accompanied by evidence for
the appeal. Appeals can be made on the following specific grounds:- that the finding of unsatisfactory performance or attendance is unreasonable;
- that there had been procedural breaches or other fairness which could have
affected the decision made;
- that there is critical new evidence that could not reasonably have been
considered at previous stages;
- that the Officer should not have been called to attend a third stage meeting as
the performance / attendance in question was no connected to the performance
/ attendance for which the Final Written Notice was issued.The tribunal panel appointed by the Local Policing Body will consist of:
• A legally qualified chair drawn from a list maintained by the Home Office;
• A member of the Local Policing Body nominated by the Body;
• A serving senior Officer (of ACPO rank)
• A retired Officer of appropriate rank also drawn from a list supplied by the
Home Office.A Tribunal chair will assess whether there is a need to conduct a hearing, or
whether the appeal is conducted on a paper basis.For further information, refer to Annex C of the Home Office Guidance.
Produced by Staffordshire Police
for FOI 23088HRD 8
Oct 13 V4.0
NOT PROTECTIVELY MARKEDProduced by Staffordshire Police
for FOI 23088
© Staffordshire Police. Reproduced for non-commercial purposes from https://www.staffordshire.police.uk/SysSiteAssets/foi-media/staffordshire/2026-published-foi-requests/july/foi-23088-hrd-08-upap-guidance-final-oct13.pdf under Staffordshire Police's publication scheme terms, which allow free reproduction if accurate and not misleading, with the source and copyright acknowledged. The text only, as read from the published documents; material owned by others is not covered. Collected on 2 September 2026; Staffordshire Police may have changed or withdrawn it since.
If this text names you or you own part of it, ask us to take the full text down: it is hidden as soon as you send the form, and the title and summary stay.
Related releases
- Accelerated misconduct hearing for PC Alex Potts Misconduct hearing notice · Staffordshire Police · 21 Sept 2026
- FOI 23366 Shotgun Certificates Disclosure log response · Staffordshire Police · 21 Sept 2026
- FOI 23389 Published News Content Disclosure log response · Staffordshire Police · 21 Sept 2026
- FOI 23393 Speed Camera Van Disclosure log response · Staffordshire Police · 21 Sept 2026
- FOI 23396 Sickness Levels Disclosure log response · Staffordshire Police · 21 Sept 2026
Ask us to remove a name from this page (free) · Report a mistake