FOI 23165 Cold Case InvestigationDisclosure log response · Staffordshire Police
FOI 23165 Cold Case Investigation
Read it at Staffordshire Police's website
- Published
- 12 Aug 2026
- Published by
- Staffordshire Police
- Source
- Staffordshire Police's website
- Recorded by PoliceFOI
- 2 Sept 2026
In full, as Staffordshire Police published it
We show a record in full only where its publisher's terms allow it. Most police forces in England and Wales publish under the same publication scheme terms: anyone may reproduce a force's own material free of charge if it is accurate and not misleading and the source and copyright are acknowledged, but not for any commercial purpose. PoliceFOI is published by a company, so we treat our use as commercial, and for those forces we show each record's title and summary, with a link to the original, until the force agrees to more. A few forces' terms are stricter still. None of these terms covers material owned by someone else, or a force's logo, so we link to such material rather than copy it.
Files
- File PDF, 199 KB
The original
The text of this file
7 August 2026 FOI Ref 23165
Request - You asked Staffordshire Police (SP) the following:
I am writing on behalf of XXXXXXX , producers of the long -running investigative podcast XXXXXXXXX
Case of Fred the Head.The podcast examines the long -running investigation into the unidentified man whose skeletal remains
were discovered in a shallow grave beside the River Trent at the Old Flint Mill, Newton Road, Winshill,
Burton upon Trent, on 27 March 1971. As we prepare future episodes, we are keen to ensure that any
references we make to Staffordshire Police's investigation accurately reflect the current forensic position.
We appreciate that this remains an open murder investigation and understand there will be matters that
cannot be discussed. Our questions are therefore limited to clarification of public statements previously
made by Staffordshire Police.In 2021, Detective Chief Inspector Dan Ison gave a number of public interviews, including one with
Staffordshire Live, in which it was stated that:
• the DNA was last tested in 2017/2018;
• Staffordshire Police now held a "full DNA profile";
• the remains were confirmed as male; and
• DNA comparisons had been undertaken, including reference to websites "such as Ancestry".
•
To assist us in ensuring our reporting is accurate, we would be grateful if you could clarify the following
points.DNA
1. Is it correct that the DNA work undertaken in 2017/2018 resulted from a new DNA extraction from
the remains, rather than re-analysis of DNA previously extracted?
2. Is it correct that the "full DNA profile" referred to in the 2021 interview includes a usable nuclear
DNA profile?
3. Is it correct that the DNA profile currently held contains sufficient nuclear DNA markers to determine
the biological sex of the remains?
4. Is it correct that Staffordshire Police's conclusion that the remains are male is based upon DNA
evidence?
5. Does Staffordshire Police still retain any biological samples from the remains for potential future
forensic testing?
6.
Investigative Genetic Genealogy1. Has Staffordshire Police ever uploaded the victim's DNA profile to AncestryDNA or any other public
consumer genealogy database?
2. Has Staffordshire Police undertaken any form of investigative genetic genealogy in an attempt to
identify the victim?Physical Exhibits
1. Does Staffordshire Police still retain the following exhibits?
• the partial upper denture
• the wedding ring
• the socks
• the binding cords
If any of these exhibits are no longer retained, have they been destroyed, returned, transferred to another
organisation, or buried with the human remains?Investigation Update
1. Could you outline any significant investigative work undertaken since 2021, including any further
forensic, genealogical or other enquiries relating to the identification of the victim?
2. If any of the investigative avenues referred to above have not been undertaken, can Staffordshire
Police confirm whether they have been considered and discounted?We appreciate your time and assistance. Our aim is simply to ensure that the information presented in our
podcast accurately reflects Staffordshire Police's current understanding of the case.SP received your request on 22/07/2026 and have processed this under the Freedom of Information Act
(FOIA).SP’s response to your enquiry is as follows:
SP holds the requested information.
DNA
1. Is it correct that the DNA work undertaken in 2017/2018 resulted from a new DNA extraction from
the remains, rather than re-analysis of DNA previously extracted? – Withheld, Section 30.2. Is it correct that the "full DNA profile" referred to in the 2021 interview includes a usable nuclear
DNA profile? – Withheld, Section 30.3. Is it correct that the DNA profile currently held contains sufficient nuclear DNA markers to determine
the biological sex of the remains? – Withheld, Section 30.4. Is it correct that Staffordshire Police's conclusion that the remains are male is based upon DNA
evidence? – Disclosed, the post-mortem examination confirmed the sex to be male.5. Does Staffordshire Police still retain any biological samples from the remains for potential future
forensic testing? – Withheld, Section 30.Investigative Genetic Genealogy
6. Has Staffordshire Police ever uploaded the victim's DNA profile to AncestryDNA or any other public
consumer genealogy database? – Withheld, Section 30.7. Has Staffordshire Police undertaken any form of investigative genetic genealogy in an attempt to
identify the victim? – Withheld, Section 30.Physical Exhibits
8. Does Staffordshire Police still retain the following exhibits?
• the partial upper denture
• the wedding ring
• the socks
• the binding cords – Withheld, Section 30.If any of these exhibits are no longer retained, have they been destroyed, returned, transferred to another
organisation, or buried with the human remains? – Withheld, Section 30.Investigation Update
1. Could you outline any significant investigative work undertaken since 2021, including any further
forensic, genealogical or other enquiries relating to the identification of the victim? – Withheld,
Section 30.1. If any of the investigative avenues referred to above have not been undertaken, can Staffordshire
Police confirm whether they have been considered and discounted? – Withheld, Section 30.The following exemption has been applied:
In accordance with Section 17(1) of the Freedom of Information Act, this letter represents a refusal notice
for this particular request.• Section 30(1)(a)(b) – Criminal Investigations
Section 30 is qualified and class based and, as such, we are required to apply the public interest test.Public Interest Test
Factors favouring disclosure under Section 30(1)(a)(b)
Disclosure of the information would improve the public’s knowledge and understanding of the investigatory
process and, as all police investigations are publicly funded, would show how public funds are being spent.Factors favouring non-disclosure under Section 30(1)(a)(b)
Disclosure of the requested information would prejudice how investigations are carried out in the future.
SP is charged with enforcing the law, preventing and detecting crime and protecting the communities SP
serves. Any release of information relating to ongoing investigations could prejudice and undermine those
investigations. The prevention and detection of such matters could therefore be hindered and therefore
risk interference with evidence, which could have detrimental impact on future investigations. In addition,
the right to a fair trial could be undermined.Balance test
Disclosure under the Freedom of Information Act is a release of information to the world in general and
not an individual applicant. Having considered the public interest factors SP are required to determine
whether on balance the factors favouring disclosure outweigh those which are against disclosure. It is SP’s
view that the factors favouring disclosure do not outweigh those which favour non-disclosure.Please be advised that all F reedom of Information request responses are published on the SP website
although personal details are not included.Freedom of Information Request Appeals Procedure
1. Who Can Ask for a Review
Any person who has requested information from SP, which has been dealt with under the Freedom of
Information Act, is entitled to complain and request an internal review, if they are dissatisfied with the
response they received.2. How to Request a Review
Requests for review of a Freedom of Information request must be made in writing within two months of the
date of receipt of this email, and should be addressed to:[removed by PoliceFOI]
Or by Post to:
Information Access Team
Staffordshire Police HQ
PO Box 3167
Stafford
ST16 9JZThe reference number, date of the request and details of why the review is being requested must be
included. Requests for review should be brought to the attention of the Information Access Team within
two months of the Force’s response to the original FOI request.3. Review Procedure
Receipt of a request for review will be acknowledged in writing. The review will be conducted by a
Supervisor who is independent from the original Decision Maker. The Information Access Team will set a
target date for a response. The response will be made as soon as is practicable with the intention to
complete the review within 20 working days. In more complex cases the review may take up to 40 working
days.The independent Supervisor will conduct a review of the handling of the request for information and of
decisions taken, including decisions taken about where the public interest lies in respect of exempt
information where applicable. The review enables a r e-evaluation of the case, taking into account the
matters raised by the complaint.4. Conclusion of the Appeal
On completion of the review the Independent Supervisor will reply to the appellant with the result of the
review. If the appellant is still dissatisfied following the review they should contact the Information
Commissioner to make an appeal. The Information Commissioner can be contacted via the following link:
https://ico.org.uk/make-a-complaint/foi-and-eir-complaints/foi-and-eir-complaints/Freedom of Information
Information Access Team
© Staffordshire Police. Reproduced for non-commercial purposes from https://www.staffordshire.police.uk/SysSiteAssets/foi-media/staffordshire/2026-published-foi-requests/august/foi-23165-cold-case-investigation.pdf under Staffordshire Police's publication scheme terms, which allow free reproduction if accurate and not misleading, with the source and copyright acknowledged. The text only, as read from the published documents; material owned by others is not covered. Collected on 2 September 2026; Staffordshire Police may have changed or withdrawn it since.
If this text names you or you own part of it, ask us to take the full text down: it is hidden as soon as you send the form, and the title and summary stay.
Related releases
- Accelerated misconduct hearing for PC Alex Potts Misconduct hearing notice · Staffordshire Police · 21 Sept 2026
- FOI 23366 Shotgun Certificates Disclosure log response · Staffordshire Police · 21 Sept 2026
- FOI 23389 Published News Content Disclosure log response · Staffordshire Police · 21 Sept 2026
- FOI 23393 Speed Camera Van Disclosure log response · Staffordshire Police · 21 Sept 2026
- FOI 23396 Sickness Levels Disclosure log response · Staffordshire Police · 21 Sept 2026
Ask us to remove a name from this page (free) · Report a mistake