PoliceFOIby Assize Data

PoliceFOI is an independent record of what police forces and the justice system are asked under the Freedom of Information Act, and what they publish. It is not the police: to report a crime, call 999 in an emergency or 101.

FOI 616/25Disclosure log response · South Wales Police

FOI request- Facial recognition safety zones

Read it at South Wales Police's website

Published
26 Jun 2025
Published by
South Wales Police
Outcome
Refused
Exemption
Source
South Wales Police's website
Recorded by PoliceFOI
2 Sept 2026

We read the outcome and the exemption automatically from the response's own words, so this can be wrong: report a mistake. What the outcomes and codes mean.

In full, as South Wales Police published it

We show a record in full only where its publisher's terms allow it. Most police forces in England and Wales publish under the same publication scheme terms: anyone may reproduce a force's own material free of charge if it is accurate and not misleading and the source and copyright are acknowledged, but not for any commercial purpose. PoliceFOI is published by a company, so we treat our use as commercial, and for those forces we show each record's title and summary, with a link to the original, until the force agrees to more. A few forces' terms are stricter still. None of these terms covers material owned by someone else, or a force's logo, so we link to such material rather than copy it.

FOI 616/25

REQUEST

I am writing to request the following information relating to South Wales Police's Zone of Safety LFR trial

  1. A copy of the Public Safety Commissioner Strategic Development document for the proposal title "Live Facial Recognition Zones of Safety"
  2. A copy of any other proposal document, project plan or similar setting out SWP's participation in the trial

RESPONSE

We consulted with our Digital services unit who have provided the following information regarding your request.

Question 1

The funding request was prepared and generated on behalf of the NPCC. Under S16 our duty to advise and assist you may wish to submit this part of your request to NPCC using the link provided below:

https://www.npcc.police.uk/contact-us/

Question 2

Your request for this information has now been considered and I am not obliged to supply the information you have requested.

In relation to your request, the following exemption applies:

Section 14(1) – Vexatious

Section 1(1) does not oblige a public authority to comply with a request for information if the request is vexatious

Under S.14 (1) there is no requirement to conduct a public interest test and no requirement to provide any information or to confirm or deny whether the information is held.

I have taken cognisance of the Information Commissioners guidance on Vexatious requests which can be found at:

http://www.ico.gov.uk/for_organisations/guidance_index/freedom_of_information_and_environmental_information.aspx

ICO guidance on the subject states:

‘Section 14(1) may be used in a variety of circumstances where a request, or its impact on a public authority, cannot be justified. Whilst public authorities should think carefully before refusing a request as vexatious, they should not regard section 14(1) as something which is only to be applied in the most extreme of circumstances.

In cases where the issue is not clear-cut, the key question to ask is whether the request is likely to cause a disproportionate or unjustified level of disruption, irritation or distress. This will usually be a matter of objectively judging the evidence of the impact on the authority and weighing this against any evidence about the purpose and value of the request. The public authority may also take into account the context and history of the request, where this is relevant.’

One of the indicators for identifying potentially vexatious requests is:

“Burden on the authority - The effort required to meet the request will be so grossly oppressive in terms of the strain on time and resources, that the authority cannot reasonably be expected to comply, no matter how legitimate the subject matter or valid the intentions of the requester”

Accordingly, I have classified your request as vexatious under section 14(1).

Our evidence and considerations in applying S14, against this backdrop is as follows:

Firstly, Freedom of Information legislation is designed to provide opportunities whereby the public can shine a torch on the decision making and workings of a public authority. However, this does not mean that information has to automatically be disclosed. To do so without significant thought process would be reckless and, in this case, could lead to the disclosure of exempt information.

There are number of drafts of the project plan in relation to this project, which includes thousands of pages. All of this information would require a manual review by our DSD (Digital Services Division) with a view to identifying harm in disclosure and redacting the exempt information accordingly. Any potentially exempt information cannot easily be isolated because it is scattered throughout the requested material. The information would also need to be reviewed by a member of the Freedom of Information Team so that the correct exemptions could be applied, and the public interest test carried out, where applicable.

It is impossible to quantify the length of time this task would take but we can safely say that it would be in excess of what could be reasonably expected to complete the initial review alone. It is not in the public interest to detract resources from a small team with a high workload whose main function is the core policing purpose of adhering to the Freedom of Information legislation. Such an abstraction would negatively affect this purpose.

I would also draw your attention to a decision notice issued by the Information Commissioner which dealt with the burdensome aspect of Section 14. This Decision Notice stated that although there was a weighty public interest in disclosure, the sheer volume of information meant that there was a ‘grossly oppressive burden’.

https://ico.org.uk/media/action-weve-taken/decision-notices/2015/1043411/fs_50561528.pdf

In accordance with the Freedom of Information Act 2000, this letter acts as a refusal notice for your request.

© South Wales Police. Reproduced for non-commercial purposes from https://www.south-wales.police.uk/foi-ai/south-wales-police/disclosure-log/2025/june/foi-61625/ under South Wales Police's publication scheme terms, which allow free reproduction if accurate and not misleading, with the source and copyright acknowledged. The text only, as read from the published documents; material owned by others is not covered. Collected on 2 September 2026; South Wales Police may have changed or withdrawn it since.

If this text names you or you own part of it, ask us to take the full text down: it is hidden as soon as you send the form, and the title and summary stay.

South Wales Police in figures

113,835 crimes recorded in the 12 months to Sept 2026; 6,273 stop and searches in the 12 months to Apr 2026. Figures from data.police.uk.

More about South Wales Police

Ask us to remove a name from this page (free) · Report a mistake