FOI T1514/24 - CCTVDisclosure log response · Northumbria Police
FOI T1514/24 - CCTV
Read it at Northumbria Police's website
- Published
- 6 Dec 2024
- Published by
- Northumbria Police
- Outcome
- Refused
- Exemption
- Section 12 Cost limit: finding the information would cost more than the limit (£450 for the police)
- Source
- Northumbria Police's website
- Recorded by PoliceFOI
- 2 Sept 2026
We read the outcome and the exemption automatically from the response's own words, so this can be wrong: report a mistake. What the outcomes and codes mean.
In full, as Northumbria Police published it
We show a record in full only where its publisher's terms allow it. Most police forces in England and Wales publish under the same publication scheme terms: anyone may reproduce a force's own material free of charge if it is accurate and not misleading and the source and copyright are acknowledged, but not for any commercial purpose. PoliceFOI is published by a company, so we treat our use as commercial, and for those forces we show each record's title and summary, with a link to the original, until the force agrees to more. A few forces' terms are stricter still. None of these terms covers material owned by someone else, or a force's logo, so we link to such material rather than copy it.
FOI T1514/24 - CCTV
We can confirm that the information you have requested is held by Northumbria Police.
We are able to disclose the located information to you as follows.
You asked:
In relation to CCTV for security of police estates only:
1. What brand of CCTV cameras are in use? If there are multiple please provide a list
A response to this part of your submission will not be provided and by withholding we rely on the following exemptions.
S24 (1) - National Security
S31 (1) (a)(b) - Law Enforcement
Sections 24, and 31 are prejudice based qualified exemptions and there is a requirement to articulate the harm that would be caused in its disclosure as well as carrying out a public interest test.
Harm
To disclose information to the public at large as to what security CCTV we have down to brand, could be used to the advantage of terrorists or criminal organisations in causing disruption or harm to both officers and staff of Northumbria Police and to members of the pubic. Information that undermines the operational integrity and security of police sites and will adversely affect public safety and have a negative impact on both national security and law enforcement should not be disclosed to the public at large.
Public Interest Test
Factors favouring disclosure - Section 24
The public are entitled to know what public funds are spent on and what security measures are in place, and by confirming what is in place would lead to a better-informed public.
Factors against disclosure - Section 24
By disclosing this information would make those security measures less effective. This would lead to the compromise of the security of police buildings and of harm to the public, ie a cyber-criminal could use such information to attack a particular CCTV system, which would then negatively affect the infrastructure of policing. By affecting the infrastructure of policing the nation’s security will be more vulnerable to terrorism.
Factors favouring disclosure - Section 31
This would enable the public to have a better understanding of the effectiveness of the police and about how the police protect its buildings, workforce and the general public using those building for whatever reason. It would greatly assist in the quality and accuracy of public debate. Where public funds are being spent, there is a public interest in accountability and justifying the use of public money.
Factors against disclosure- Section 31
The release of this type of information would better inform those will ill intent how to target a cyber-attack within the police estate. If a force was hacked and this lead to CCTV systems not working efficiently then a negative impact would occur to the prevention or detection of crime and the security of both staff and members of the public. Cyber-crime can lead to forces being unable to carry out their objectives. Northumbria Police would not want to provide information that could lead to criminals being better informed on the vulnerabilities, or perceived vulnerabilities a force has, or to target any security systems being utilised. The realise of such information would facilitate criminals or those with criminal intent to launch cyber-attacks which then may result in illegal access to police CCTV systems and undermine the security of police sites. Obviously this is to be avoided.
Balance Test
The security of Northumbria Police and of the country is of paramount importance and the Police service will not divulge any information if to do so would place the safety of any building, workforce or individual at risk, undermine National Security or compromise law enforcement.
Whilst there is a public interest in the transparency of policing operations and providing assurance that the police service is appropriately and effectively engaging with the threat posed by various groups or individuals, there is a very strong public interest in safeguarding the integrity of police systems, investigations and operations in the highly sensitive areas such as extremism, crime prevention, public disorder and terrorism prevention.
We have therefore considered the information held about CCTV hardware is at a level which would risk exploitation by criminals to infiltrate cameras, and thus compromise the security of police sites.
As much as there is public interest in knowing that policing activity is appropriate and balanced this will only be overridden in exceptional circumstances. The detail sought would reveal security systems and therefore it is our opinion that for these issues the balancing test for disclosure is not made out.
2. How many cameras are in list across the estate? (If there are multiple vendors please could you provide a breakdown of how many devices per vendor)
348
3. What is the annual spend on new CCTV cameras?
There is no dedicated annual budget for replacement of CCTV cameras. As per our response to point 5 below, cameras are replaced on failure, however if we were asked to identify actual costs this would exceed the permitted 18-hour threshold and Section 12 would then be applicable and your whole request refused. Rather than do so we have supplied as much information as we have been able to in order to assist.
4. Who is the senior officer (outside of procurement) responsible for this?
Head of Estates. They can be contacted by email: [removed by PoliceFOI]
5. When did you last replace the cameras?
Cameras are replaced on failure
6. When are the existing cameras due to be replaced?
As above, cameras are replaced on failure
© Northumbria Police. Reproduced for non-commercial purposes from https://www.northumbria.police.uk/foi-ai/northumbria-police/disclosure-log-2024/foi-t151424---cctv/ under Northumbria Police's publication scheme terms, which allow free reproduction if accurate and not misleading, with the source and copyright acknowledged. The text only, as read from the published documents; material owned by others is not covered. Collected on 2 September 2026; Northumbria Police may have changed or withdrawn it since.
If this text names you or you own part of it, ask us to take the full text down: it is hidden as soon as you send the form, and the title and summary stay.
Related releases
- Misconduct hearing for PC John Flaherty Misconduct hearing notice · Northumbria Police · 14 Sept 2026
- Misconduct hearing for former PC Peter Miller Misconduct hearing notice · Northumbria Police · 26 Aug 2026
- FOI/2732 Manslaughter Disclosure log response · Northumbria Police · 24 Apr 2026
- FOI/1880 Hate Crime Disclosure log response · Northumbria Police · 23 Apr 2026
- FOI/1943 Collisions Disclosure log response · Northumbria Police · 23 Apr 2026
Ask us to remove a name from this page (free) · Report a mistake